Department of Neurology, Kuala Lumpur Hospital, Kuala Lumpur, Ministry of Health of Malaysia.
Department of Radiology, Kuala Lumpur Hospital, Kuala Lumpur, Ministry of Health of Malaysia.
Mult Scler Relat Disord. 2018 Oct;25:300-308. doi: 10.1016/j.msard.2018.07.003. Epub 2018 Aug 1.
We performed a retrospective observational analytical study looking at the frequencies and characteristics of multiple sclerosis(MS) and neuromyelitis optica spectrum disorders(NMOSD) in consecutive patients with idiopathic inflammatory demyelinating disease (IIDDs) attending three centers (2009-2017). Of 523 patients with IIDDs, there were 173 patients with NMOSD and 230 patients with MS. The percentage of NMOSD: IIDDs was 33%. The percentage of NMOSD:Total MS and NMOSD cohort was 43%. Of 141 seropositive NMOSD patients, 134(95%) were from the three main ethnic groups. The percentage of seropositive NMOSD to IIDDs and to combined MS and NMOSD was 26.9% and 35% respectively. Ratios of MS to NMOSD were nearly equal at 1.3 to 1.0, reinforcing the high ratio of NMOSD to MS in Asia. Nearly half of the Chinese cohort were seropositive ie; 71/141 (50%) with the remainder being Malays; 56/141 (39.7%) and Indians; 7/141 (5%). Amongst the other indigenous groups seropositivity was seen in 2 each of Iban, Bajau, Kadazan descent as well as one of Bidayuh origin. Comparatively, seropositivity in NMOSD is commoner amongst the Chinese compared to the Malays (p ≤ 0.005) and Indians, p ≤ 0.05 with ratios as high as 10:1. In the MS group of 230 subjects, 123(53.5%) were Malays (ratio of MS:NMOSD of 2:1), 41(17.8%) were Chinese, (ratio of MS:NMOSD of 0.5:1.0) and 54 (23.5%)were Indians (ratios of MS:NMOSD of 5:1 amongst the Indians). The remainder from East Malaysia were made up of 2 each of Kadazans, Ibans and Bajaus including 3 each of Bidayuh and Eurasian descent. Comparatively, in the NMOSD and MS cohorts a female preponderance was noted more so amongst Chinese NMOSD patients, with rare familial occurrence in both but more in Malay MS/NMOSD patients. This study also highlighted some of the inter-ethnic differences in presentation of MS and NMOSD amongst the 3 main ethnic races in Malaysia and confirms indigenous races having MS/NMOSD which needs further research. It also reviewed current literature on similar inter-ethnic differences world wide. To conclude, MS and NMOSD are the commonest demyelinating diseases seen in Malaysia with interesting inter-ethnic differences and similarities.
我们进行了一项回顾性观察分析研究,观察了在三个中心就诊的特发性炎症性脱髓鞘疾病(IIDD)连续患者中多发性硬化症(MS)和视神经脊髓炎谱系障碍(NMOSD)的频率和特征(2009-2017 年)。在 523 名 IIDD 患者中,有 173 名 NMOSD 患者和 230 名 MS 患者。NMOSD:IIDD 的百分比为 33%。NMOSD:总 MS 和 NMOSD 队列的百分比为 43%。在 141 名血清阳性 NMOSD 患者中,有 134 名(95%)来自三个主要种族。血清阳性 NMOSD 与 IIDD 和联合 MS 和 NMOSD 的百分比分别为 26.9%和 35%。MS 与 NMOSD 的比值几乎相等,为 1.3 比 1.0,这强化了亚洲 NMOSD 与 MS 比值高的事实。中国队列中有近一半的患者呈血清阳性,即 141 名中的 71 名(50%)为中国人;56/141(39.7%)和印度人;7/141(5%)。在其他土著群体中,有 2 名伊班人、2 名巴瑶族人和 2 名卡达人呈血清阳性,还有 1 名比达尤人呈血清阳性。相对而言,NMOSD 中的血清阳性在中国人中比在马来人和印度人中更为常见(p≤0.005),比值高达 10:1。在 230 名 MS 患者中,有 123 名(53.5%)为马来人(MS:NMOSD 的比值为 2:1),41 名(17.8%)为中国人,(MS:NMOSD 的比值为 0.5:1.0),54 名(23.5%)为印度人(印度人 MS:NMOSD 的比值为 5:1)。其余来自东马来西亚的患者由 2 名卡达人、2 名伊班人和 2 名巴瑶族组成,其中包括 3 名比达尤人和 3 名欧亚裔。相对而言,在 NMOSD 和 MS 队列中,中国 NMOSD 患者中女性居多,马来人 MS/NMOSD 患者中也有罕见的家族性病例,但更多。这项研究还强调了马来西亚三个主要种族中 MS 和 NMOSD 之间存在的一些种族间差异,并证实了土著种族存在 MS/NMOSD,这需要进一步研究。它还回顾了全球范围内关于类似种族间差异的当前文献。总之,MS 和 NMOSD 是马来西亚最常见的脱髓鞘疾病,具有有趣的种族间差异和相似性。