From the Section of Plastic Surgery, Department of Surgery, The University of Michigan Medical School, Ann Arbor (APY, HEH); Stritch School of Medicine, Loyola University, Chicago, IL (ALM); Department of Surgery, Division of Plastic Surgery, University of Wisconsin Health System, Madison, WI (BFM); Section of Plastic Surgery, Assistant Dean for Faculty Affairs, The University of Michigan Medical School, Ann Arbor (KCC).
J Am Board Fam Med. 2018 Sep-Oct;31(5):795-804. doi: 10.3122/jabfm.2018.05.170423.
Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) for soft-tissue wrist injury may be overprescribed, contributing to ineffective health care resource use. We aimed to discern predictive factors that may improve MRI's application in soft-tissue wrist injury.
We conducted a retrospective chart review of adults who underwent MRIs for possible soft-tissue wrist injury between June 2009 and June 2014. Clinical data and treatment recommendations before and after MRI were analyzed. If the MRI-directed treatment recommendation was different from before MRI, the MRI was noted to have influenced the patient's treatment (Impact MRI).
Among 140 MRI scans, 39 (28%) impacted treatment recommendation. Twenty-six Impact MRIs were ordered by hand surgeons, whereas 13 were ordered by referring physicians ( = .001). More Impact MRIs were found when an MRI was ordered for patients younger than 36 years ( = .01), within 6 weeks of symptom onset ( = .03), to question a specific anatomic injury ( = .0001), or by a board-certified hand surgeon ( = .001). Adjusting for other covariates, these 4 clinical factors were identified as independent predictive factors to Impact MRIs.
MRIs for soft-tissue wrist injuries may more likely change management when the patient is younger, ordered within 6 weeks of symptom onset, and prescribed with a specific differential diagnosis. Referral to a hand surgeon should be considered before wrist MRI for the following patients: history of hand surgery/trauma, older than 36 years likely due to confounding chronic wrist changes, symptomatic for more than 6 weeks, and without clear differential diagnoses for the symptoms.
磁共振成像(MRI)在软组织手腕损伤中的应用可能被过度开具,导致医疗资源使用效率低下。我们旨在确定可能改善 MRI 在软组织手腕损伤中的应用的预测因素。
我们对 2009 年 6 月至 2014 年 6 月间接受 MRI 检查以诊断可能的软组织手腕损伤的成年人进行了回顾性图表审查。分析了 MRI 前后的临床数据和治疗建议。如果 MRI 指导的治疗建议与 MRI 前不同,则认为 MRI 影响了患者的治疗(影响 MRI)。
在 140 例 MRI 扫描中,39 例(28%)影响了治疗建议。26 例影响性 MRI 由手外科医生开具,而 13 例由转诊医生开具( =.001)。当 MRI 是为 36 岁以下的患者、症状出现后 6 周内、为了质疑特定的解剖损伤、或由手外科医生开具时,发现更多的影响性 MRI( =.01、 =.03、 =.0001、 =.001)。在调整其他协变量后,这 4 个临床因素被确定为影响 MRI 的独立预测因素。
对于年轻患者、症状出现后 6 周内、具有特定鉴别诊断的软组织手腕损伤患者,MRI 更有可能改变治疗方案。对于有手部手术/创伤史、年龄大于 36 岁(可能因慢性手腕变化导致混杂因素)、症状持续超过 6 周且症状无明确鉴别诊断的患者,在进行手腕 MRI 检查之前,应考虑转诊至手外科医生。