Centre for International Health, Department of Global Public Health and Primary Care, University of Bergen, Norway; Centre for Intervention Science in Maternal and Child Health (CISMAC), University of Bergen, Norway.
Centre MURAZ, Ministère de la Santé, Bobo-Dioulasso, Burkina Faso; Department of Public Health, Université d'Ouagadougou I, Burkina Faso.
Soc Sci Med. 2018 Oct;215:28-35. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2018.09.001. Epub 2018 Sep 4.
Targets and indicators set at the global level are powerful tools that govern health systems in low-income countries. Skilled birth attendance at a health facility is an important indicator for monitoring maternal mortality reduction worldwide. This paper examines how health workers negotiate policy implementation through the translation of clinical care into registries and reports. It does so by analysing the links between the global policy of institutional births and the role of documentation in the provision of birth care in primary health centres in Burkina Faso. Observations of health workers' practices in four primary maternity units (one urban, one semi-urban and two rural) conducted over a 12-week period in 2011-2012 are analysed alongside 14 in-depth interviews with midwives and other health workers. The findings uncover the magnitude of reporting demands that health workers experience and the pressure placed on them to provide the 'right' results, in line with global policy objectives. The paper describes the way in which they document inaccurate accounts, for example by completing the labour surveillance tool partograph after birth, thus transforming it into a 'postograph', to adhere to the expectations of health district officers. We argue that the drive for the 'right' numbers might encourage inaccurate reporting practices and it can feed into policies that are incapable of addressing the realities experienced by frontline health workers and patients. The focus on producing indicators of good care can divert attention from actual care, with profound implications for accountability at the health centre level.
目标和指标设定在全球一级是治理低收入国家卫生系统的有力工具。在卫生机构熟练接生是监测全世界降低产妇死亡率的一个重要指标。本文通过分析临床护理转化为登记册和报告的过程,研究卫生工作者如何通过翻译政策来实施。它分析了全球机构分娩政策与文档在布基纳法索初级保健中心提供分娩护理方面的作用之间的联系。2011-2012 年期间,在四个初级产妇单位(一个城市、一个半城市和两个农村)进行了为期 12 周的卫生工作者实践观察,并对 14 名助产士和其他卫生工作者进行了深入访谈。研究结果揭示了卫生工作者所经历的报告需求的巨大压力,以及他们按照全球政策目标提供“正确”结果的压力。本文描述了他们记录不准确账目(例如,在分娩后填写劳动监测工具产程图,将其转变为“postograph”)的方式,以符合卫生区官员的期望。我们认为,对“正确”数字的追求可能会鼓励不准确的报告做法,并可能导致无法解决一线卫生工作者和患者所面临的现实的政策。关注良好护理指标的生产可能会转移对实际护理的注意力,这对卫生中心层面的问责制有深远影响。