1 Headache Center of Greater Heights, Memorial Hermann Greater Heights Hospital, Houston, TX, USA.
2 Department of Anesthesia, Critical Care and Pain Medicine, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Boston, MA, USA.
Cephalalgia. 2019 Apr;39(4):556-563. doi: 10.1177/0333102418801585. Epub 2018 Sep 14.
The therapeutic benefit of nerve decompression surgeries for chronic headache/migraine are controversial.
To provide clinical characteristics of headache type and treatment outcome of occipital nerve decompression surgery.
A retrospective review of clinical records. Inclusion criteria were evidence of chronic occipital headache with and without migrainous features and tenderness of neck muscles, occipital allodynia, and inadequate response to prophylactic drugs.
Surgical decompression of the greater and lesser occipital nerves provided complete and extended (3-6 years) relief of new daily persistent headache in case 3 (46 year old female), and of chronic post-traumatic headache in cases 4 and 6 (35 and 30 year old females, respectively), partial relief of chronic headache/migraine in cases 1 and 2 (41 year old female and 36 year old male), and no relief of episodic (cases 3 and 4) or chronic migraine (case 5, 52 year old male), or chronic tension-type headache (case 7, 31 year old male).
As a case series, this study cannot test a hypothesis or determine cause and effect. However, the complete elimination of new daily persistent headache and post-traumatic headache, and the partial elimination of chronic headache/migraine in two patients - all refractory to other treatment approaches - supports and justifies the effort to continue to generate data that can help determine whether decompression nerve surgeries are beneficial in the treatment of certain types of chronic headache.
神经减压手术治疗慢性头痛/偏头痛的疗效存在争议。
提供枕神经减压手术的头痛类型和治疗结果的临床特征。
回顾性临床病历分析。纳入标准为慢性枕部头痛伴或不伴偏头痛特征、颈肌压痛、枕部感觉过敏和预防性药物治疗反应不佳。
第三例(46 岁女性)新发持续性每日头痛,第四例和第六例(35 岁和 30 岁女性)慢性创伤后头痛,第一例和第二例(41 岁女性和 36 岁男性)慢性头痛/偏头痛部分缓解,第三例和第四例(35 岁和 30 岁女性)发作性头痛和第五例(52 岁男性)慢性偏头痛,以及第七例(31 岁男性)慢性紧张型头痛均无缓解。
作为一项病例系列研究,本研究不能检验假设或确定因果关系。然而,两名患者的新发持续性头痛和创伤后头痛完全消除,以及两名患者的慢性头痛/偏头痛部分消除(均对其他治疗方法有反应),支持并证明了继续收集数据的必要性,这些数据有助于确定神经减压手术是否对某些类型的慢性头痛的治疗有益。