Earnshaw Valerie A, Reisner Sari L, Menino David, Poteat V Paul, Bogart Laura M, Barnes Tia N, Schuster Mark A
Department of Human Development and Family Sciences, University of Delaware, Newark, Delaware, USA.
Division of General Pediatrics, Boston Children's Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts, USA.
Dev Rev. 2018 Jun;48:178-200. doi: 10.1016/j.dr.2018.02.001. Epub 2018 Feb 22.
Youth living with socially devalued characteristics (e.g., minority sexual orientation, race, and/or ethnicity; disability; obesity) experience frequent bullying. This stigma-based bullying undermines youths' wellbeing and academic achievement, with lifelong consequences. The National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine recommends developing, implementing, and evaluating evidence-based interventions to address stigma-based bullying. To characterize the existing landscape of these interventions, we conducted a systematic review of stigma-based bullying interventions targeting youth in any country published in the peer-reviewed literature between 2000 and 2015. Our analysis was guided by a theoretical framework of stigma-based bullying, which describes stigma-related factors at the societal, structural, interpersonal, and individual levels that lead to stigma-based bullying. We screened 8,240 articles and identified 22 research studies describing 21 interventions addressing stigma-based bullying. We found that stigma-based bullying interventions are becoming more numerous, yet are unevenly distributed across stigmas, geographic locations, and types of organizations. We further found that these interventions vary in the extent to which they incorporate theory and have been evaluated with a wide range of research designs and types of data. We recommend that future work address stigma-based bullying within multicomponent interventions, adopt interdisciplinary and theory-based approaches, and include rigorous and systematic evaluations. Intervening specifically on stigma-related factors is essential to end stigma-based bullying and improve the wellbeing of youth living with socially devalued characteristics.
具有社会贬值特征(例如少数性取向、种族和/或族裔、残疾、肥胖)的青少年经常遭受欺凌。这种基于污名的欺凌会损害青少年的幸福感和学业成绩,并产生终身影响。美国国家科学院、工程院和医学院建议制定、实施和评估基于证据的干预措施,以应对基于污名的欺凌。为了描述这些干预措施的现有情况,我们对2000年至2015年间发表在同行评审文献中的、针对任何国家青少年的基于污名的欺凌干预措施进行了系统综述。我们的分析以基于污名的欺凌的理论框架为指导,该框架描述了在社会、结构、人际和个人层面上导致基于污名的欺凌的与污名相关的因素。我们筛选了8240篇文章,确定了22项研究,这些研究描述了21种针对基于污名的欺凌的干预措施。我们发现,基于污名的欺凌干预措施越来越多,但在不同污名、地理位置和组织类型之间分布不均。我们还发现,这些干预措施在纳入理论的程度以及采用广泛的研究设计和数据类型进行评估方面存在差异。我们建议未来的工作在多成分干预措施中应对基于污名的欺凌,采用跨学科和基于理论的方法,并包括严格和系统的评估。专门针对与污名相关的因素进行干预对于消除基于污名的欺凌并改善具有社会贬值特征的青少年的幸福感至关重要。