Sahin-Ilkorkor Zehra, Brubaker Sarah Jane
L. Douglas Wilder School of Government and Public Affairs, Virginia Commonwealth University, Richmond, VA 23284, USA.
Behav Sci (Basel). 2025 Jan 13;15(1):61. doi: 10.3390/bs15010061.
In this conceptual article, the authors provide a narrative review of literature on bullying and sexual harassment in K-12 schools framed through a comparative analysis of risk and protective factors for both forms of violence across the social-ecological spectrum. We find that a greater number of studies of both forms of violence focus on student and microsystem-level factors rather than on higher levels of the ecosystem including school boards, neighborhoods, and broader cultural norms. In addition, the research overwhelmingly identifies more risk factors than protective factors. Finally, we find more similarities than differences in risk and protective factors between the two forms of school-based violence. We identify implications of the findings for theory, research, and policy and suggest that preventing any form of harassment at school will benefit not only students but the entire school community. We argue that the causes of school-based harassment are complex and require comprehensive prevention, intervention, and response approaches that address shared risk and protective factors, particularly those at the community and mesosystem, exosystem, and macrosystem levels. Ultimately, we argue that all community stakeholders must be committed to and engaged in these endeavors for them to be successful.
在这篇概念性文章中,作者通过对社会生态范围内两种暴力形式的风险和保护因素进行比较分析,对K-12学校中的欺凌和性骚扰文献进行了叙述性综述。我们发现,针对这两种暴力形式的研究更多地关注学生和微观系统层面的因素,而非生态系统的更高层面,如学校董事会、社区及更广泛的文化规范。此外,研究中压倒性地识别出更多的风险因素而非保护因素。最后,我们发现这两种校内暴力形式在风险和保护因素方面的相似之处多于差异。我们确定了这些发现对理论、研究和政策的影响,并指出预防校内任何形式的骚扰不仅将使学生受益,还将使整个学校社区受益。我们认为,校内骚扰的成因复杂,需要采取全面的预防、干预和应对措施,以应对共同的风险和保护因素,特别是那些在社区和中观系统、外部系统及宏观系统层面的因素。最终,我们认为所有社区利益相关者必须致力于并参与这些努力,以使它们取得成功。