Riebel T, Knop J, Winkler K, Delling G
Rofo. 1986 Oct;145(4):365-72. doi: 10.1055/s-2008-1048952.
In 16 patients with a long bone osteosarcoma treated after the therapy regimen of COSS 80/82 (Cooperative Osteosarcoma Study) the tumour response to preoperative chemotherapy was assessed by conventional roentgenograms (plain films, tomograms, angiograms). The histological grade of regression determined in the operative specimen was used as a reference for the extent of tumour devitalisation. By their different typical roentgenological course the osteosarcomas with a very good and those with a rather poor response could be correctly identified (100%). On following the clinically used differentiation between "good responders" (histological grades I to III) and "poor responders" (grades IV to VI) the corresponding classification of these tumours by roentgenograms and functional scintigraphic imaging was found to be correct in 94% of the cases. The coincidence of the correct as well as the false results in both radiological methods was as high as 100% if those osteosarcomas showing only a "medium response" in their roentgenograms were added to the clinical group of good responders. There were no fundamentally discrepant results obtained by each of the two radiological techniques. With the combined workup of the roentgenological and the scintigraphic material any incorrect preoperative estimation of tumour regression with a harmful influence on therapy (date and type of surgery, mode of postoperative chemotherapy) could be avoided.
对16例采用COSS 80/82(骨肉瘤合作研究)治疗方案治疗的长骨骨肉瘤患者,通过传统X线片(平片、体层摄影、血管造影)评估肿瘤对术前化疗的反应。将手术标本中确定的组织学消退分级用作肿瘤失活程度的参考。通过其不同的典型X线影像学过程,可以正确识别反应非常好和反应相当差的骨肉瘤(100%)。按照临床上对“良好反应者”(组织学分级I至III)和“不良反应者”(分级IV至VI)的区分,通过X线片和功能闪烁显像对这些肿瘤进行相应分类,结果在94%的病例中是正确的。如果将那些在X线片上仅显示“中等反应”的骨肉瘤加入良好反应者的临床组,两种放射学方法中正确结果和错误结果的一致性高达100%。两种放射学技术均未获得根本不一致的结果。通过X线影像学和闪烁显像材料的联合检查,可以避免对治疗有有害影响的术前对肿瘤消退的错误估计(手术日期和类型、术后化疗方式)。