Chiafery Marianne C, Hopkins Patrick, Norton Sally A, Shaw Margie Hodges
Clinical Nursing, University of Rochester School of Nursing, Rochester, New York, and Medical Humanities and Bioethics, University of Rochester School of Medicine, Rochester, New York, USA. Marianne_Chiafery@urmc. rochester.edu.
Clinical Nursing, University of Rochester School of Nursing, Rochester, New York, USA. Patrick
J Clin Ethics. 2018 Fall;29(3):217-226.
Moral distress (MD) is an emotional and psychological response to morally challenging dilemmas. Moral distress is experienced frequently by nurses in the intensive care unit (ICU) and can result in emotional anguish, work dissatisfaction, poor patient outcomes, and high levels of nurse turnover. Opportunities to discuss ethically challenging situations may lessen MD and its associated sequela.
The purpose of this project was to develop, implement, and evaluate the impact of nursing ethics huddles on participants' MD, clinical ethics knowledge, work satisfaction, and patient care among ICU nurses.
The sample, 32 nurses from three ICU settings in an 800-bed tertiary academic medical center, participated in six nursing ethics huddles over a two-month period.
Alvita K. Nathaniel's Theory of Moral Reckoning guided development of the nursing ethics huddle process. The Moral Distress Thermometer was administered at three data points: baseline level of MD, and pre- and post-huddle to determine changes in the subjects' level of MD. Focused content analysis was used to analyze qualitative responses from questionnaires about the subjects' perception of the effect of the huddles on work satisfaction and patient care. Knowledge attainment was evaluated via open-ended short-answer questions.
Overall, use of nurse-ethicist-led nursing ethics huddles was associated with improved quality of work life, patient care, and clinical ethics knowledge. The change in pre- and post-nursing ethics huddles MD scores was statistically significant.
道德困扰(MD)是对道德挑战性困境的一种情绪和心理反应。重症监护病房(ICU)的护士经常经历道德困扰,这可能导致情绪痛苦、工作不满、患者预后不良以及护士高离职率。讨论道德挑战性情况的机会可能会减轻道德困扰及其相关后果。
本项目的目的是开发、实施并评估护理伦理小组讨论对ICU护士参与者的道德困扰、临床伦理知识、工作满意度和患者护理的影响。
样本为一家拥有800张床位的三级学术医疗中心三个ICU科室的32名护士,她们在两个月的时间里参加了六次护理伦理小组讨论。
阿尔维塔·K·纳撒尼尔的道德清算理论指导了护理伦理小组讨论过程的开发。在三个数据点使用道德困扰温度计:道德困扰的基线水平,以及小组讨论前和讨论后,以确定受试者道德困扰水平的变化。采用聚焦内容分析法分析问卷中关于受试者对小组讨论对工作满意度和患者护理影响的定性回答。通过开放式简答题评估知识掌握情况。
总体而言,由护士伦理学家主导的护理伦理小组讨论的使用与工作生活质量、患者护理和临床伦理知识的改善相关。护理伦理小组讨论前后道德困扰得分的变化具有统计学意义。