Kashiwabara Kosuke, Matsuyama Yutaka, Ohashi Yasuo
1 Department of Biostatistics, School of Public Health, Graduate School of Medicine, the University of Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan.
Ther Innov Regul Sci. 2014 Jul;48(4):444-452. doi: 10.1177/2168479014525378.
In an ongoing clinical trial, there will always be a risk for unanticipated critical safety problems, such as excessive occurrence of serious adverse events. When such a problem arises, the trial administrators must conduct an immediate evaluation to determine whether the trial should be terminated to protect patients. This decision is complicated but may be aided by statistical stopping rules. Sequential stopping rules are appropriate for immediate decisions, but frequentist approaches may not be useful because the unknown truncated end of the trial makes it impossible to define type I errors. Thus, a Bayesian stopping rule is proposed that is based on the posterior distribution with an informative prior distribution, and a guideline to construct this stopping rule is presented. Some operating characteristics are evaluated and compared with those of the modified sequential probability ratio test (SPRT), the maximized SPRT, and Pocock's test. The proposed method has flexibility for construction and could provide a more desirable performance than the other compared methods.
在一项正在进行的临床试验中,始终存在出现意外严重安全问题的风险,例如严重不良事件的过度发生。当出现此类问题时,试验管理人员必须立即进行评估,以确定是否应终止试验以保护患者。这一决定很复杂,但统计停止规则可能会有所帮助。序贯停止规则适用于立即做出决策,但频率学派方法可能无用,因为试验未知的截断终点使得无法定义I型错误。因此,提出了一种基于具有信息先验分布的后验分布的贝叶斯停止规则,并给出了构建此停止规则的指南。评估了一些操作特性,并与修正的序贯概率比检验(SPRT)、最大化SPRT和Pocock检验的操作特性进行了比较。所提出的方法在构建上具有灵活性,并且可以提供比其他比较方法更理想的性能。