Sims-Gould Joanie, Race Douglas L, Macdonald Heather, Houghton Kristin M, Duffy Ciarán M, Tucker Lori B, McKay Heather A
University of British Columbia, Vancouver, Canada.
Centre for Hip Health and Mobility, 2635 Laurel Street, Vancouver, BC, V5Z 1M9, Canada.
Pediatr Rheumatol Online J. 2018 Sep 20;16(1):59. doi: 10.1186/s12969-018-0273-6.
Physical activity is essential for ensuring optimal physical function and fitness in children with juvenile idiopathic arthritis (JIA). Although exercise intervention trials informed current clinical practice, few studies addressed why children with JIA do or do not participate in exercise interventions. We aimed to describe perceived barriers and facilitators to the uptake and adherence to a 6-month home-based exercise intervention for children diagnosed with JIA and their parents.
A convenience sample of children (n = 17) and their parents (n = 17) were recruited from a group of 23 child-parent dyads participating in an exercise intervention study; the Linking Exercise, Activity and Pathophysiology Exercise Intervention (LEAP-EI) study. Child-parent dyads completed in-depth semi-structured one-to-one interviews with a trained interview moderator prior to starting the exercise program and 11 dyads completed follow-up interviews at the end of the 6-month program. We also conducted 'exit' interviews with one child-parent dyad, one child and one parent following three participants' withdrawal from the exercise intervention. Interviews were transcribed and transcripts were analyzed using a five-step framework analysis to categorize data into themes.
Thematic analysis of pre-exercise program interview transcripts revealed three reasons child-parent dyads initiated the exercise program: 1) potential health benefits, 2) selflessness and 3) parental support. Analysis of post-exercise intervention transcripts identified four main themes within a priori themes of barriers and facilitators to program adherence (median of 46.9%; 5.4, 66.7 IQR): 1) parental support, 2) enjoyment, 3) time pressures (subthemes: time requirement of exercise, scheduling, forgetting) and 4) physical ailments.
Major barriers to and facilitators to exercise for children with JIA fell into three categories: personal, social and programmatic factors. These barriers were not unlike those that emerged in previous exercise intervention trials with healthy children and youth. There is a need to develop effective strategies to engage children in physical activity and to overcome barriers that prevent them from doing so. Future initiatives may potentially engage children in developing solutions to enhance their participation in and commitment to physical activity.
体育活动对于确保幼年特发性关节炎(JIA)患儿的最佳身体功能和健康状况至关重要。尽管运动干预试验为当前临床实践提供了依据,但很少有研究探讨JIA患儿参与或不参与运动干预的原因。我们旨在描述被诊断为JIA的患儿及其父母接受并坚持为期6个月的家庭运动干预的感知障碍和促进因素。
从参与运动干预研究的23对儿童-父母二元组中选取了一个便利样本,包括17名儿童及其17名父母;即“运动、活动与病理生理学联系运动干预(LEAP-EI)研究”。在开始运动计划之前,儿童-父母二元组与一名经过培训的访谈主持人进行了深入的一对一的半结构化访谈,11对二元组在6个月计划结束时完成了随访访谈。在三名参与者退出运动干预后,我们还对一对儿童-父母二元组、一名儿童和一名父母进行了“退出”访谈。访谈内容被转录,转录本使用五步框架分析法进行分析,以便将数据分类为主题。
运动计划前访谈转录本的主题分析揭示了儿童-父母二元组启动运动计划的三个原因:1)潜在的健康益处,2)无私,3)父母的支持。运动干预后转录本的分析在先验的计划坚持障碍和促进因素主题中确定了四个主要主题(中位数为46.9%;四分位距为5.4,66.7):1)父母的支持,2)乐趣感,3)时间压力(子主题:运动的时间要求、日程安排、遗忘),4)身体疾病。
JIA患儿运动的主要障碍和促进因素分为三类:个人因素、社会因素和计划因素。这些障碍与之前针对健康儿童和青少年的运动干预试验中出现的障碍并无不同。有必要制定有效的策略,让儿童参与体育活动,并克服阻碍他们这样做的障碍。未来的举措可能会让儿童参与制定解决方案,以提高他们对体育活动的参与度和投入度。