Arosio Fabrizio, Guasti Maria Teresa
a Department of Psychology , Università degli Studi di Milano-Bicocca , Milano , Italy.
Clin Linguist Phon. 2019;33(4):349-375. doi: 10.1080/02699206.2018.1517191. Epub 2018 Sep 21.
We aim at determining whether 7-year-old Italian-speaking children with Specific Language Impairment (SLI): (1) have problems with the production of wh- questions; (2) display a subject/object asymmetry in producing which- and who questions; (3) attempt to simplify questions, especially which- questions; (4) have difficulties with movement and verbal agreement in wh- questions. We elicited subject and object who and which NP questions in 10 children with SLI (M = 7;2), in 10 chronological age (CA)-matched controls (M = 7;2) and 10 language-matched controls (M = 5;2). Results showed that (1) children with SLI produced fewer questions than both control groups; (2) a subject/object asymmetry was observed in who questions but not in which NP questions; (3) which NP questions were more problematic than who questions; (4) children with SLI produced more agreement errors and resorted to simplification strategies to avoid wh- question production. Results point to a grammatical deficit due to the computation of complex grammatical relations and suggest that there is a misalignment among pieces of linguistic competence needed to form Italian wh- questions (wh- movement and agreement computation). Outcomes have implications for clinical assessment recommending the production of wh- questions to be considered in the evaluation of SLI in Italian.
我们旨在确定患有特定语言障碍(SLI)的7岁讲意大利语儿童是否:(1)在生成wh-疑问句方面存在问题;(2)在生成which-和who疑问句时表现出主语/宾语不对称;(3)试图简化疑问句,尤其是which-疑问句;(4)在wh-疑问句中存在移位和动词一致方面的困难。我们在10名患有SLI的儿童(平均年龄7岁2个月)、10名年龄匹配的对照儿童(平均年龄7岁2个月)和10名语言匹配的对照儿童(平均年龄5岁2个月)中引出了主语和宾语who以及which名词短语疑问句。结果表明:(1)患有SLI的儿童生成的疑问句比两个对照组都少;(2)在who疑问句中观察到主语/宾语不对称,但在which名词短语疑问句中未观察到;(3)which名词短语疑问句比who疑问句问题更多;(4)患有SLI的儿童出现更多的一致错误,并采用简化策略来避免生成wh-疑问句。结果表明,由于复杂语法关系的计算存在语法缺陷,并表明在形成意大利语wh-疑问句所需的语言能力要素(wh-移位和一致计算)之间存在不一致。研究结果对临床评估具有启示意义,建议在意大利语SLI评估中考虑生成wh-疑问句。