Department of Obstetrics & Gynecology, Cumming School of Medicine, University of Calgary, Calgary, Alberta, Canada.
Department of Obstetrics & Gynecology, Oregon Health & Science University, Portland, OR.
Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2018 Dec;219(6):523.e1-523.e15. doi: 10.1016/j.ajog.2018.09.015. Epub 2018 Sep 18.
This Enhanced Recovery After Surgery (ERAS) Guideline for perioperative care in cesarean delivery will provide best practice, evidenced-based, recommendations for preoperative, intraoperative, and postoperative phases with, primarily, a maternal focus. The focused pathway process for scheduled and unscheduled cesarean delivery for this ERAS Cesarean Delivery Guideline will consider from the time from decision to operate (starting with the 30-60 minutes before skin incision) to hospital discharge. The literature search (1966-2017) used Embase and PubMed to search medical subject headings that included "Cesarean Section," "Cesarean Section," "Cesarean Section Delivery" and all pre- and intraoperative ERAS items. Study selection allowed titles and abstracts to be screened by individual reviewers to identify potentially relevant articles. Metaanalyses, systematic reviews, randomized controlled studies, nonrandomized controlled studies, reviews, and case series were considered for each individual topic. Quality assessment and data analyses that evaluated the quality of evidence and recommendations were evaluated according to the Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development and Evaluation system, as used and described in previous ERAS Guidelines. The ERAS Cesarean Delivery Guideline/Pathway has created a maternal focused pathway (for scheduled and unscheduled surgery starting from 30-60 minutes before skin incision to maternal discharge) with ERAS cesarean delivery consensus recommendations preoperative elements (anesthetic medications, fasting, carbohydrate supplementation, prophylactic antibiotics/skin preparation, ), intraoperative elements (anesthetic management, maternal hypothermia prevention, surgical technique, hysterotomy creation and closure, management of peritoneum, subcutaneous space, and skin closure), perioperative fluid management, and postoperative elements (chewing gum, management of nausea and vomiting, analgesia, timing of food intake, glucose management, antithrombotic prophylaxis, timing of ambulation, urinary management, and timing of maternal and neonate discharge). Limited topics for optimized care and for antenatal education and counselling and the immediate neonatal needs at delivery are discussed. Strong recommendations for element use were given for preoperative (antenatal education and counselling, use of antacids and histamine, H2 receptor antagonists, 2-hour fasting and small meal within 6 hours surgery, antimicrobial prophylaxis and skin preparation/chlorhexidine-alcohol), intraoperative (regional anesthesia, prevention of maternal hypothermia [forced warm air, warmed intravenous fluids, room temperature]), perioperative (fluid management for euvolemia and neonatal immediate care needs that include delayed cord clamping), and postoperative (fluid management to prevent nausea and vomiting, antiemetic use, analgesia with nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drugs/paracetamol, regular diet within 2 hours, tight capillary glucose control, pneumatic compression stocking for venous thromboembolism prophylaxis, immediate removal of urinary catheter). Recommendations against the element use were made for preoperative (maternal sedation, bowel preparation), intraoperative (neonatal oral suctioning or increased inspired oxygen), and postoperative (heparin should not be used routinely venous thromboembolism prophylaxis). Because these ERAS cesarean delivery pathway recommendations (elements/processes) are studied, implemented, audited, evaluated, and optimized by the maternity care teams, this will create an opportunity for the focused and optimized areas of care research with further enhanced care and recommendation.
本《手术后快速康复(ERAS)剖宫产围手术期护理指南》旨在为产妇提供最佳实践和循证推荐,涵盖术前、术中和术后各阶段。本指南以剖宫产为重点,以产妇为中心。剖宫产 ERAS 指南的计划性和非计划性剖宫产的聚焦路径流程将从决定手术开始(从切皮前 30-60 分钟开始)到出院。文献检索(1966-2017 年)使用 Embase 和 PubMed 搜索了包括“剖宫产”、“剖宫产”、“剖宫产分娩”和所有术前和术中 ERAS 项目的医学主题词。研究选择允许单独的评审员筛选标题和摘要,以确定潜在相关文章。对每个主题都考虑了荟萃分析、系统评价、随机对照研究、非随机对照研究、综述和病例系列。根据 Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development and Evaluation 系统(如之前的 ERAS 指南中所述和使用)评估了质量评估和数据分析,以评估证据和建议的质量。ERAS 剖宫产指南/路径为计划性和非计划性手术(从切皮前 30-60 分钟开始至产妇出院)创建了一个以产妇为中心的路径,其中包含 ERAS 剖宫产的共识推荐,包括术前元素(麻醉药物、禁食、碳水化合物补充、预防性抗生素/皮肤准备)、术中元素(麻醉管理、产妇低体温预防、手术技术、子宫切开术和缝合、腹膜、皮下组织和皮肤闭合的管理)、围手术期液体管理和术后元素(咀嚼口香糖、恶心和呕吐的管理、镇痛、进食时间、血糖管理、抗血栓形成预防、活动时间、尿管理和产妇和新生儿出院时间)。讨论了优化护理和产前教育咨询以及分娩时新生儿即刻需求的有限主题。对术前(产前教育咨询、使用抗酸剂和组胺、H2 受体拮抗剂、2 小时禁食和 6 小时内小餐手术、抗菌预防和皮肤准备/洗必泰酒精)、术中(区域麻醉、预防产妇低体温[强制热空气、加热静脉输液、室温])、围手术期(液体管理以达到血容量正常和新生儿即刻护理需求,包括延迟脐带夹闭)和术后(液体管理以预防恶心和呕吐、使用止吐药、使用非甾体抗炎药/扑热息痛镇痛、术后 2 小时内进食常规饮食、严格控制毛细血管血糖、使用气动压缩袜预防静脉血栓栓塞、立即取出导尿管)等元素的使用给予了强烈推荐。对术前(产妇镇静、肠道准备)、术中(新生儿口腔抽吸或增加吸入氧)和术后(肝素不应常规用于静脉血栓栓塞预防)等元素的使用提出了反对建议。由于这些 ERAS 剖宫产途径推荐(元素/流程)由产科护理团队进行研究、实施、审核、评估和优化,因此将为重点和优化的护理研究领域创造机会,并进一步增强护理和建议。