Routier Alexandre, Habert Marie-Odile, Bertrand Anne, Kas Aurélie, Sundqvist Martina, Mertz Justine, David Pierre-Maxime, Bertin Hugo, Belliard Serge, Pasquier Florence, Bennys Karim, Martinaud Olivier, Etcharry-Bouyx Frédérique, Moreaud Olivier, Godefroy Olivier, Pariente Jérémie, Puel Michèle, Couratier Philippe, Boutoleau-Bretonnière Claire, Laurent Bernard, Migliaccio Raphaëlla, Dubois Bruno, Colliot Olivier, Teichmann Marc
Institut du Cerveau et de la Moelle épinière, ICM, Inserm U 1127, CNRS UMR 7225, Sorbonne Université, FrontLab, Paris, France.
Inria, Aramis Project-Team, Paris, France.
Front Neurol. 2018 Sep 18;9:766. doi: 10.3389/fneur.2018.00766. eCollection 2018.
Neuroimaging studies have described the brain alterations in primary progressive aphasia (PPA) variants (semantic, logopenic, nonfluent/agrammatic). However, few studies combined T1, FDG-PET, and diffusion MRI techniques to study atrophy, hypometabolism, and tract alterations across the three PPA main variants. We therefore explored a large early-stage cohort of semantic, logopenic and nonfluent/agrammatic variants ( = 86) and of 23 matched healthy controls with anatomical MRI (cortical thickness), FDG PET (metabolism) and diffusion MRI (white matter tracts analyses), aiming at identifying cortical and sub-cortical brain alterations, and confronting these alterations across imaging modalities and aphasia variants. In the semantic variant, there was cortical thinning and hypometabolism in anterior temporal cortices, with left-hemisphere predominance, extending toward posterior temporal regions, and affecting tracts projecting to the anterior temporal lobes (inferior longitudinal fasciculus, uncinate fasciculus) and tracts projecting to or running nearby posterior temporal cortices: (superior longitudinal fasciculus, inferior frontal-occipital fasciculus). In the logopenic variant metabolic alterations were more extensive than atrophy affecting mainly the left temporal-parietal junction and extending toward more anterior temporal cortices. Metabolic and tract data were coherent given the alterations of the left superior and inferior longitudinal fasciculus and the left inferior frontal-occipital fasciculus. In the nonfluent/agrammatic variant cortical thinning and hypometabolism were located in the left frontal cortex but Broca's area was only affected on metabolic measures. Metabolic and tract alterations were coherent as reflected by damage to the left uncinate fasciculus connecting with Broca's area. Our findings provide a full-blown statistically robust picture of brain alterations in early-stage variants of primary progressive aphasia which has implications for diagnosis, classification and future therapeutic strategies. They demonstrate that in logopenic and semantic variants patterns of brain damage display a non-negligible overlap in temporal regions whereas they are substantially distinct in the nonfluent/agrammatic variant (frontal regions). These results also indicate that frontal networks (combinatorial syntax/phonology) and temporal networks (lexical/semantic representations) constitute distinct anatomo-functional entities with differential vulnerability to degenerative processes in aphasia variants. Finally, the identification of the specific damage patterns could open an avenue for trans-cranial stimulation approaches by indicating the appropriate target-entry into the damaged language system.
神经影像学研究已经描述了原发性进行性失语(PPA)各变体(语义性、音韵性、非流利/语法缺失性)中的脑改变。然而,很少有研究结合T1、FDG-PET和弥散MRI技术来研究三种PPA主要变体中的萎缩、代谢减退和神经束改变。因此,我们对语义性、音韵性和非流利/语法缺失性变体(n = 86)以及23名匹配的健康对照者组成的大型早期队列进行了解剖学MRI(皮质厚度)、FDG PET(代谢)和弥散MRI(白质束分析),旨在识别皮质和皮质下脑改变,并比较这些改变在不同成像模态和失语变体中的情况。在语义性变体中,颞前叶皮质出现皮质变薄和代谢减退,以左侧半球为主,向后颞叶区域延伸,并影响投射至颞前叶的神经束(下纵束、钩束)以及投射至后颞叶皮质或在其附近走行的神经束:(上纵束、额枕下束)。在音韵性变体中,代谢改变比萎缩更广泛,主要影响左侧颞顶交界处,并向前颞叶皮质延伸。考虑到左侧上下纵束和左侧额枕下束的改变,代谢和神经束数据是一致的。在非流利/语法缺失性变体中,皮质变薄和代谢减退位于左侧额叶皮质,但仅在代谢测量中发现布洛卡区受影响。代谢和神经束改变是一致的,这表现为连接布洛卡区的左侧钩束受损。我们的研究结果提供了原发性进行性失语早期变体脑改变的全面且具有统计学稳健性的情况,这对诊断、分类和未来治疗策略具有重要意义。它们表明,在音韵性和语义性变体中,脑损伤模式在颞叶区域存在不可忽视的重叠,而在非流利/语法缺失性变体(额叶区域)中则有显著差异。这些结果还表明,额叶网络(组合句法/音韵学)和颞叶网络(词汇/语义表征)构成了不同的解剖功能实体,在失语变体中对退行性过程具有不同的易损性。最后,特定损伤模式的识别可以通过指明进入受损语言系统的合适靶点,为经颅刺激方法开辟一条途径。