Bartl W, Pfersmann C, Schlögl H, Dadak C
Wien Klin Wochenschr. 1986 Dec 5;98(23):797-803.
The correlation between clinical findings, mammography and thermography on the one hand and histological structure of the breast on the other hand, was investigated in 133 women. Palpable changes in the breast parenchyma indicated excision biopsy in all cases. The following criteria were employed for palpatory assessment: size, differentiation, nodular mobility and consistency. For mammography, criteria such as calcification, opacity, contralateral comparison and skin thickening were used. For thermography, a modified "Gautherie score" was employed. All three palpatory parameters, however, do not provide reliable differentiation between benign and malignant tumours, since the palpatory findings in fibrocystic disease are similar to those in large malignant growths. Small malignant growths, in turn, may resemble benign tumours. Furthermore, the group of fibrocystic disease markedly reduces the specificity of the radiological findings. However, as aid to differential diagnosis it may be said that apart from the shape of the shadow, contralateral difference in appearance is more likely to occur with benign and malignant tumours than with fibrocystic disease. With regard to thermography a low score i.e. an unconspicuous picture of heat distribution is unlikely to signify a malignant growth. It is, however, impossible to distinguish between mastopathy and malignant tumour. Additional investigations i.e. mammography and thermography do not rule out the existence of a malignant growth.
对133名女性进行了研究,以探讨临床检查结果、乳房X光摄影和热成像与乳房组织结构之间的相关性。乳房实质的可触及变化在所有病例中均表明需进行切除活检。触诊评估采用以下标准:大小、分化程度、结节活动度和质地。乳房X光摄影使用钙化、不透光、双侧对比和皮肤增厚等标准。热成像采用改良的“高特里评分”。然而,所有这三个触诊参数都无法可靠地区分良性和恶性肿瘤,因为纤维囊性疾病的触诊结果与大型恶性肿瘤相似。反之,小型恶性肿瘤可能类似良性肿瘤。此外,纤维囊性疾病组显著降低了放射学检查结果的特异性。然而,作为鉴别诊断的辅助手段,可以说除了阴影形状外,良性和恶性肿瘤比纤维囊性疾病更有可能出现双侧外观差异。关于热成像,低分即热分布不明显的图像不太可能表示恶性肿瘤。然而,无法区分乳腺病和恶性肿瘤。额外的检查,即乳房X光摄影和热成像,并不能排除恶性肿瘤的存在。