Jeanne Wirpsa M, Emily Johnson Rebecca, Bieler Joan, Boyken Lara, Pugliese Karen, Rosencrans Emily, Murphy Patricia
a Northwestern Memorial Hospital , Chicago , Illinois.
b Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine , Chicago , Illinois.
J Health Care Chaplain. 2019 Jan-Mar;25(1):20-44. doi: 10.1080/08854726.2018.1501131. Epub 2018 Oct 15.
Shared decision making (SDM) is a central component of patient-centered care; however, a minimal amount is known about what health care chaplains contribute to this process. Data from 463 full-time chaplains practicing in the United States collected by an online survey was analyzed using SPSS 26 for bivariate and multivariate logistical regressions to identify variables impacting chaplain integration into SDM. Coding of free text responses yielded multiple domains for chaplain contributions and barriers. Thirty-eight percent of chaplains reported being often or frequently integrated into health care team discussions regarding medical decisions, with years of professional experience, time spent supporting the emotional processing of medical decisions, and being well-prepared as the strongest predictors for high integration. Qualitative analysis yielded a multifaceted picture that includes chaplain attention to the impact religion has on decision making, a focus on the patient story, and chaplains as mediators between patients, families, and the health care team. The full integration of chaplains into SDM will require education of the interdisciplinary team regarding the scope of chaplain knowledge and skills, as well as organizational level changes in chaplain to patient ratios and coverage models. In this era of increased fragmentation of health care provision and advancing complexity of medical decision making, models of Interprofessional Shared Decision Making (IP-SDM) such as the one proposed here that appreciate the specialized knowledge and skills of each member of the health care team hold promise for enhancing patient-centered care.
共同决策(SDM)是以患者为中心的医疗服务的核心组成部分;然而,对于医疗保健牧师在这一过程中的贡献,人们所知甚少。通过在线调查收集了463名在美国执业的全职牧师的数据,并使用SPSS 26进行双变量和多变量逻辑回归分析,以确定影响牧师融入共同决策的变量。对自由文本回复的编码产生了牧师贡献和障碍的多个领域。38%的牧师报告说,他们经常或频繁地参与医疗团队关于医疗决策的讨论,其中专业经验年限、支持医疗决策情感处理所花费的时间以及充分准备是高度融入的最强预测因素。定性分析得出了一个多方面的情况,包括牧师关注宗教对决策的影响、关注患者故事以及牧师作为患者、家庭和医疗团队之间的调解人。要使牧师完全融入共同决策,需要对跨学科团队进行关于牧师知识和技能范围的教育,以及在牧师与患者的比例和覆盖模式方面进行组织层面的变革。在这个医疗服务日益分散、医疗决策日益复杂的时代,像本文提出的这种认识到医疗团队每个成员专业知识和技能的跨专业共同决策(IP-SDM)模式,有望加强以患者为中心的医疗服务。