Markell Mariana S, Terebelo Sima
Department of Medicine, Division of Renal Diseases Box 52, SUNY Downstate Medical Center, 450 Clarkson Ave, Brooklyn, NY, United States.
Department of Medicine, Division of Renal Diseases Box 52, SUNY Downstate Medical Center, 450 Clarkson Ave, Brooklyn, NY, United States.
Explore (NY). 2018 Nov;14(6):414-419. doi: 10.1016/j.explore.2018.04.010. Epub 2018 Sep 12.
Complementary Medicine (CAM) is often used by patients with chronic illness and may not be disclosed to health care providers without prompting. In other populations, patients who use CAM were more likely to alter medications without discussing it with their provider. This study examined the relationship between self-reported use of CAM, attitudes toward care, and adherence to medical therapy in a population of inner-City kidney transplant recipients.
Cross-sectional observational analysis in a random convenience sample from the outpatient transplant clinic. Data were obtained via face-to-face structured closed-ended interview using validated survey instruments.
45% of patients reported using CAM. Of the study participants who used CAM, 39.1% reported non-adherence to immunosuppressant medications within the past three months, while among the non-CAM users, 17.9% reported non-adherence (p value=0.084). Adherence to hypoglycemic medication was significantly lower CAM users,(p=0.029). Patients who reported having somatic symptoms were more likely to use CAM. Symptom sum was significantly associated with CAM use, p=0.030, with 47.8% CAM users reporting skin problems vs. 10.7% non-CAM users,p=0.003 and 17.4% CAM users noting loss of appetite, compared to 3.5% of non-CAM users,p=0.002 In a random subgroup of 26 patients, 15% who did not use CAM reported medication side effects, while 53% of CAM users reported them, p =0.039.
Use of CAM was common in our kidney transplant population. Patients who use CAM reported more somatic symptoms, more medication side effects and were more likely to be non-adherent to non-immunosuppressant medications. Positive response to questions about CAM use may be a surrogate marker for high symptom burden and risk of non-adherence to non-immunosuppresion medications in kidney transplant recipients.
慢性病患者常使用补充替代医学(CAM),若不主动提及,可能不会告知医护人员。在其他人群中,使用CAM的患者更有可能在未与医护人员讨论的情况下自行调整用药。本研究调查了市中心肾移植受者群体中自我报告的CAM使用情况、护理态度与药物治疗依从性之间的关系。
对门诊移植诊所的随机便利样本进行横断面观察分析。通过使用经过验证的调查工具进行面对面的结构化封闭式访谈获取数据。
45%的患者报告使用CAM。在使用CAM的研究参与者中,39.1%报告在过去三个月内未坚持服用免疫抑制药物,而在未使用CAM的患者中,17.9%报告未坚持服药(p值 = 0.084)。CAM使用者对降糖药物的依从性显著较低(p = 0.029)。报告有躯体症状的患者更有可能使用CAM。症状总数与CAM使用显著相关,p = 0.030,47.8%的CAM使用者报告有皮肤问题,而未使用CAM的患者为10.7%,p = 0.003;17.4%的CAM使用者表示食欲不振,未使用CAM的患者为3.5%,p = 0.002。在26名患者的随机子组中,15%未使用CAM的患者报告有药物副作用,而53%的CAM使用者报告有药物副作用,p = 0.039。
CAM在我们的肾移植人群中使用普遍。使用CAM的患者报告有更多的躯体症状、更多的药物副作用,并且更有可能不坚持服用非免疫抑制药物。对CAM使用问题的肯定回答可能是肾移植受者高症状负担和不坚持服用非免疫抑制药物风险的替代指标。