de Lima Moreno Jorge Javier, Liedke Gabriela Salatino, Soler Roberto, da Silveira Heloisa Emília Dias, da Silveira Heraldo Luis Dias
1Department of Maxillofacial Prosthesis, School of Dentistry, Universidad de la Republica, Las Heras 1925, Montevideo, Uruguay.
2Department of Stomatology, School of Dentistry, Federal University of Santa Maria, Santa Maria, Brazil.
J Maxillofac Oral Surg. 2018 Dec;17(4):582-587. doi: 10.1007/s12663-018-1098-z. Epub 2018 Feb 28.
To compare reconstructed area and surface roughness of 3D models acquired using nine image acquisition protocols. Radiation dose was also compared among acquisition protocols.
A dry craniofacial specimen was scanned using three CT devices (a cone beam CT, a 16-channel fan beam CT, and a 64-channel fan beam CT), with three different acquisition protocols each. Nine 3D models were manufactured using polylactic acid. Surface roughness and reconstructed area were determined for each 3D model. The radiation dose during acquisitions was measured using lithium crystals. ANOVA was used to compare the data among the 3D models. Linear function optimization techniques based on stochastic variables were applied to identify the most suitable protocol for use.
For surface roughness, statistically significant differences were observed among all 3D models and the specimen. For reconstructed area, CBCT and one CT-16 channel protocols originated 3D models statistically significant different from the specimen. Higher radiation doses were observed with fan beam CT acquisitions.
All three CT devices were suitable for 3D printing when used at full resolution. The highest reconstruct area vs. radiation dose ratio was found for 64-channel CT devices.
比较使用九种图像采集协议获取的3D模型的重建面积和表面粗糙度。还比较了各采集协议之间的辐射剂量。
使用三台CT设备(一台锥形束CT、一台16通道扇形束CT和一台64通道扇形束CT)对一个干燥的颅面部标本进行扫描,每种设备使用三种不同的采集协议。使用聚乳酸制造九个3D模型。测定每个3D模型的表面粗糙度和重建面积。使用锂晶体测量采集过程中的辐射剂量。采用方差分析比较3D模型之间的数据。应用基于随机变量的线性函数优化技术来确定最合适的使用协议。
对于表面粗糙度,在所有3D模型和标本之间观察到统计学上的显著差异。对于重建面积,锥形束CT和一种16通道CT协议生成的3D模型与标本在统计学上有显著差异。扇形束CT采集时观察到较高的辐射剂量。
当以全分辨率使用时,所有三台CT设备都适用于3D打印。64通道CT设备的重建面积与辐射剂量之比最高。