Postgraduate of Public Health, Federal University of Rio Grande do Norte, Natal, Brazil.
Department of Nutrition, Federal University of Rio Grande do Norte, Natal, Brazil.
PLoS One. 2018 Oct 23;13(10):e0205642. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0205642. eCollection 2018.
Estimating equations can be used when measuring the height of elderly persons is not possible. However, such methods are not always applicable; therefore, it is necessary to consider several aspects, such as sex, age, and ethnicity of the studied population to generate these equations. This study aimed to compare and validate methods of estimating the height of the Brazilian elderly nursing home residents. An accuracy study was conducted with 168 elderly persons. A total of 23 equations were quantitatively evaluated by plotting the differences in means, the Student's t-test for paired samples, the coefficient of determination (R2), the root-mean-square error (RMSE), the interclass correlation coefficient (ICC), and by graphic analysis of the residuals. A significance value of p <0.05 was adopted. An equation was considered applicable when it had R2 >0.7, the lowest RMSE among the equations evaluated, ICC >0.7, and a confidence interval of 95%, with the smallest difference between the upper and lower limits. A greater mean height was noted among younger elderly persons and elderly men compared to up to 80 years and women elderly. Quantitative analysis revealed that equation for Puerto Ricans, using knee height and age, was the most applicable for the overall population (ICC = 0.802). The same equation was applicable for the elderly Brazilian male participants (ICC = 0.838) and for those aged 60-69 years (ICC = 0.895). None of the equations used were applicable for the height estimation of elderly women or individuals aged 70 years or more.
当无法测量老年人的身高时,可以使用估算方程。然而,这种方法并不总是适用;因此,有必要考虑研究人群的性别、年龄和种族等几个方面,以生成这些方程。本研究旨在比较和验证用于估算巴西养老院老年居民身高的方法。对 168 名老年人进行了一项准确性研究。通过绘制均值差异图、配对样本学生 t 检验、决定系数 (R2)、均方根误差 (RMSE)、组内相关系数 (ICC) 以及残差的图形分析,对总共 23 个方程进行了定量评估。采用 p<0.05 的显著性水平。当方程具有 R2>0.7、评估的方程中 RMSE 最低、ICC>0.7 以及置信区间为 95%、上限和下限之间的差异最小时,认为该方程适用。与 80 岁及以上的女性老年人相比,年轻的和男性老年人的平均身高更高。定量分析表明,使用膝高和年龄的波多黎各方程对于整个人群最适用 (ICC=0.802)。对于巴西老年男性参与者 (ICC=0.838) 和 60-69 岁的参与者 (ICC=0.895),同样的方程也适用。没有一个方程适用于估计老年女性或 70 岁及以上的个体的身高。