Conkin Johnny, Sanders Robert W, Koslovsky Matthew D, Wear Mary L, Kozminski Andrew G, Abercromby Andrew F J
Aerosp Med Hum Perform. 2018 Nov 1;89(11):941-951. doi: 10.3357/AMHP.5135.2018.
A review of decompression sickness (DCS) cases associated with the NASA altitude physiological training (APT) program at the Johnson Space Center (JSC) motivated us to place our findings into the larger context of DCS prevalence from other APT centers. We reviewed JSC records from 1999 to 2016 and 14 publications from 1968 to 2004 about DCS prevalence in other APT programs. We performed a meta-analysis of 15 APT profiles (488 cases / 385,116 exposures). We used meta-regression to evaluate the relation between estimated exposures and probability of DCS in a test group, accounting for the heterogeneity between studies. Our in-house review identified 6 Type I DCS (1 from an inside observer) and 1 Type II DCS. There were 6 cases in 9560 student hypobaric exposures from 3 NASA training flights; a student pooled prevalence rate of 0.44 cases / 1000 exposures compared to 1.44 cases / 1000 from 12 published APT profiles. The overall pooled DCS prevalence rate was 1.16 cases / 1000 exposures. There was substantial heterogeneity in DCS prevalence across studies. Denitrogenation time, exposure pressure, and exposure time were associated with probability of DCS in the meta-regression model. While the overall DCS prevalence rate is relatively low, there is marked heterogeneity among profiles. The pooled DCS prevalence rate estimate for the NASA profiles was lower than the overall rate. Variability in APT profile DCS prevalence could be further explained given student level and additional test-level covariates.
对与美国国家航空航天局约翰逊航天中心(JSC)的高空生理训练(APT)项目相关的减压病(DCS)病例进行回顾后,我们有动力将我们的研究结果置于来自其他APT中心的DCS患病率这一更大的背景中。我们查阅了JSC从1999年至2016年的记录以及1968年至2004年关于其他APT项目中DCS患病率的14篇出版物。我们对15个APT概况(488例/385,116次暴露)进行了荟萃分析。我们使用荟萃回归来评估测试组中估计暴露量与DCS发生概率之间的关系,同时考虑到研究之间的异质性。我们内部的回顾确定了6例I型DCS(其中1例来自内部观察者)和1例II型DCS。在来自美国国家航空航天局3次训练飞行的9560次学生低压暴露中有6例;学生汇总患病率为0.44例/1000次暴露,相比之下,从12篇已发表的APT概况中得出的患病率为1.44例/1000次暴露。总体汇总DCS患病率为1.16例/1000次暴露。各研究之间DCS患病率存在很大异质性。在荟萃回归模型中,去氮时间、暴露压力和暴露时间与DCS发生概率相关。虽然总体DCS患病率相对较低,但各概况之间存在明显异质性。美国国家航空航天局概况的汇总DCS患病率估计低于总体患病率。考虑到学生水平和其他测试水平的协变量,APT概况中DCS患病率的变异性可能会得到进一步解释。