Department of Environmental Health, Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, Boston, MA, USA.
Department of Geography and Resource Management, The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, China.
Environ Pollut. 2019 Jan;244:440-450. doi: 10.1016/j.envpol.2018.10.064. Epub 2018 Oct 15.
Air pollution exposure characterization has been shaped by many constraints. These include technologies that lead to insufficient coverage across space and/or time in order to characterize individual or community-level exposures with sufficient accuracy and precision. However, there is now capacity for continuous monitoring of many air pollutants using comparatively inexpensive, real-time sensors. Crucial questions remain regarding whether or not these sensors perform adequately for various potential end uses and whether performance varies over time or across ambient conditions. Performance scrutiny of sensors via lab- and field-testing and calibration across their lifetime is necessary for interpretation of data, and has important implications for end users including cost effectiveness and ease of use. We developed a comparatively lower-cost, portable, in-home air sampling platform and a guiding development and maintenance workflow that achieved our goal of characterizing some key indoor pollutants with high sensitivity and reasonable accuracy. Here we describe the process of selecting, validating, calibrating, and maintaining our platform - the Environmental Multi-pollutant Monitoring Assembly (EMMA) - over the course of our study to-date. We highlight necessary resources and consider implications for communities or researchers interested in developing such platforms, focusing on PM, NO, and NO sensors. Our findings emphasize that lower-cost sensors should be deployed with caution, given financial and resource costs that greatly exceed sensor costs, but that selected community objectives could be supported at lesser cost and community-based participatory research strategies could be used for more wide-ranging goals.
空气污染暴露特征描述受到许多限制的影响。这些限制包括技术方面的限制,这些技术导致在空间和/或时间上的覆盖范围不足,无法以足够的准确性和精密度来描述个体或社区层面的暴露情况。然而,现在已经有能力使用相对廉价、实时的传感器来连续监测许多空气污染物。现在仍然存在一些关键问题,例如这些传感器是否能够充分适用于各种潜在的用途,以及它们的性能是否会随时间或环境条件而变化。为了对数据进行解释,有必要通过实验室和现场测试以及在整个生命周期内进行校准来对传感器进行性能审查,这对包括成本效益和易用性在内的最终用户具有重要意义。我们开发了一个相对低成本、便携式、家庭内空气采样平台和一个指导开发和维护工作流程的系统,该系统实现了我们用高灵敏度和合理的准确性来描述一些关键室内污染物的目标。在这里,我们描述了在我们迄今为止的研究过程中,选择、验证、校准和维护我们的平台(环境多污染物监测组件(EMMA))的过程。我们强调了必要的资源,并考虑了对有兴趣开发此类平台的社区或研究人员的影响,重点是 PM、NO 和 NO 传感器。我们的研究结果强调,应该谨慎使用低成本传感器,因为其财务和资源成本大大超过传感器成本,但可以以较低的成本支持选定的社区目标,并可以使用基于社区的参与式研究策略来实现更广泛的目标。