Piotrowski Wojciech Jerzy, Adam Białas, Gwadera Łukasz, Kumor-Kisielewska Anna, Fijałkowski Marek, Kurmanowska Zofia, Marczak Jerzy, Górski Witold, Angowski Wojciech, Górski Paweł, Kwiatkowska Sylwia
Department of Pneumology and Allergy, Chair of Internal Medicine, Medical University of Lodz, Poland.
Adv Respir Med. 2018;86(5):234-239. doi: 10.5603/ARM.2018.0037.
Sarcoidosis and tuberculosis (TB) are the diseases that share many similarities. Mycobacterium tuberculosis (MTB) culture results are the gold standard for the diagnosis of TB, but false positive results are not rare. The aim was to evaluate the utility of QFT in detecting latent TB infection in a group of sarcoidosis patients with negative history of TB and negative culture/BACTEC results, and checking sarcoidosis activity influence on the QFT results. Additionally, we assessed if QFT negative result may strengthen the suspicion that positive culture/BACTEC results are false positive.
37 culture-negative and 6 culture-positive sarcoidosis patients were enrolled. On the basis of clinical and radiological data TB was considered unlikely (false-positive results). A control group consisted of age-matched subjects with excluded TB (n = 37). QuantiFERON-TB GOLD In-Tube (QIAGEN, USA) was used according to the manual. Test validity was checked basing on the results obtained from a low-risk (n = 21) and active TB group (n = 23).
The frequency of positive results tended to be higher in MTB(-) sarcoidosis (24.3% vs. 13.5% for the control group, p = 0.37), but was similar to the general population. None of culture-positive sarcoidosis patients was QFT-positive. The positive results were equally distributed among patients with active and inactive sarcoidosis.
QFT has been found to be the useful test for the detection of latent TB infection in sarcoidosis patients. In addition, we confirm that sarcoidosis activity does not negatively influence the result of QFT. Moreover, QFT would be proposed as a cost-saving diagnostic test providing additional diagnostic information when false positive MTB culture result in the sarcoidosis patient is highly suspected. However, in each case clinical, radiological and epidemiological data should be considered before taking the therapeutic decision.
结节病和结核病有许多相似之处。结核分枝杆菌(MTB)培养结果是结核病诊断的金标准,但假阳性结果并不罕见。本研究旨在评估QuantiFERON-TB金标检测(QFT)在一组无结核病史且培养/BACTEC检测结果为阴性的结节病患者中检测潜伏性结核感染的效用,并检查结节病活动度对QFT结果的影响。此外,我们评估了QFT阴性结果是否会增强对培养/BACTEC检测结果为假阳性的怀疑。
纳入37例培养结果阴性和6例培养结果阳性的结节病患者。根据临床和放射学数据,认为结核病可能性不大(假阳性结果)。对照组由年龄匹配且排除结核病的受试者组成(n = 37)。按照说明书使用QuantiFERON-TB金标管(QIAGEN,美国)。根据低风险组(n = 21)和活动性结核组(n = 23)的结果检查检测有效性。
MTB(-)结节病患者的阳性结果频率趋于更高(24.3% 对比对照组的13.5%,p = 0.37),但与一般人群相似。培养结果阳性的结节病患者中无一例QFT阳性。阳性结果在活动性和非活动性结节病患者中分布均匀。
已发现QFT是检测结节病患者潜伏性结核感染的有用检测方法。此外,我们证实结节病活动度不会对QFT结果产生负面影响。此外,当高度怀疑结节病患者MTB培养结果为假阳性时,QFT可作为一种节省成本的诊断检测方法,提供额外的诊断信息。然而,在每种情况下,在做出治疗决定之前都应考虑临床、放射学和流行病学数据。