Brooks Chris, Eden Gabrielle, Chang Andrew, Demanuele Charmaine, Kelley Erb Michael, Shaafi Kabiri Nina, Moss Mark, Bhangu Jaspreet, Thomas Kevin
Department of Anatomy and Neurobiology, Boston University School of Medicine, Boston, MA, USA.
Department of Anatomy and Neurobiology, Boston University School of Medicine, Boston, MA, USA.
J Clin Neurosci. 2019 Mar;61:174-179. doi: 10.1016/j.jocn.2018.10.043. Epub 2018 Oct 29.
The Movement Disorder Society's Unified Parkinson's Disease Rating Scale (MDS-UPDRS) is the current gold standard means of assessing disease state in Parkinson's disease (PD). Objective measures in the form of wearable sensors have the potential to improve our ability to monitor symptomology in PD, but numerous methodological challenges remain, including integration into the MDS-UPDRS. We applied a structured video coding scheme to temporally quantify clinical, scripted, motor tasks in the MDS-UPDRS for the alignment and integration of objective measures collected in parallel.
25 PD subjects completed two video-recorded MDS-UPDRS administrations. Visual cues of task performance reliably identifiable in video recordings were used to construct a structured video coding scheme. Postural transitions were also defined and coded. Videos were independently coded by two trained non-expert coders and a third expert coder to derive indices of inter-rater agreement.
50 videos of MDS-UPDRS performance were fully coded. Non-expert coders achieved a high level of agreement (Cohen's κ > 0.8) on all postural transitions and scripted motor tasks except for Postural Stability (κ = 0.617); this level of agreement was largely maintained even when more stringent thresholds for agreement were applied. Durations coded by non-expert coders and expert coders were significantly different (p < 0.05) for only Postural Stability and Rigidity, Left Upper Limb.
Non-expert coders consistently and accurately quantified discrete behavioral components of the MDS-UPDRS using a structured video coding scheme; this represents a novel, promising approach for integrating objective and clinical measures into unified, longitudinal datasets.
运动障碍协会统一帕金森病评定量表(MDS-UPDRS)是目前评估帕金森病(PD)疾病状态的金标准方法。可穿戴传感器形式的客观测量方法有潜力提高我们监测PD症状的能力,但仍存在许多方法学挑战,包括与MDS-UPDRS的整合。我们应用了一种结构化视频编码方案,对MDS-UPDRS中的临床、脚本化运动任务进行时间量化,以实现并行收集的客观测量数据的对齐和整合。
25名PD患者完成了两次视频记录的MDS-UPDRS评定。利用视频记录中可靠识别的任务表现视觉线索构建结构化视频编码方案。还定义并编码了姿势转换。视频由两名经过培训的非专业编码人员和一名专家编码人员独立编码,以得出评分者间一致性指数。
对50段MDS-UPDRS表现的视频进行了完整编码。除姿势稳定性(κ = 0.617)外,非专业编码人员在所有姿势转换和脚本化运动任务上均达成了高度一致性(Cohen's κ>0.8);即使应用更严格的一致性阈值,这种一致性水平在很大程度上仍得以保持。仅在姿势稳定性和左侧上肢僵硬方面,非专业编码人员和专家编码人员编码的持续时间存在显著差异(p<0.05)。
非专业编码人员使用结构化视频编码方案一致且准确地量化了MDS-UPDRS的离散行为成分;这代表了一种将客观测量和临床测量整合到统一纵向数据集中的新颖且有前景的方法。