Piantoni Lucas, Tello Carlos A, Remondino Rodrigo G, Francheri Wilson Ida A, Galaretto Eduardo, Noel Mariano A
Servicio de Patología Espinal, Hospital de Pediatría Prof. Dr. Juan P. Garrahan, Combate de los Pozos 1881, C1245AAM CABA Buenos Aires, Argentina.
Scoliosis Spinal Disord. 2018 Oct 26;13:23. doi: 10.1186/s13013-018-0158-y. eCollection 2018.
Currently, there is little consensus on how or when to discontinue bracing in adolescent idiopathic scoliosis (AIS). An expert spine surgeon national survey could aid in elucidate discontinuation of the brace.Few data have been published on when and how to discontinue bracing treatment in patients with AIS resulting in differences in the management of the condition. The aim of this study was to characterize decision-making of surgeons in the management of bracing discontinuation in AIS.
An original electronic survey consisting of 12 multiple choice questions was sent to all the members of the National Spine Surgery Society (497 surveyed). Participants were asked about their type of medical practice, years of experience in the field, society memberships, type of brace they usually prescribed, average hours of daily brace wearing they recommended, and how and when they indicated bracing discontinuation as well as the clinical and/or imaging findings this decision was based on. Exclusion criteria include brace discontinued because of having developed a curve that warranted surgical treatment.
Of a total of 497 surgeons, 114 responded the survey (22.9%). 71.9% had more than 5 years of experience in the specialty, and 51% mainly treated pediatric patients. Overall, 95.5% of the surgeons prescribed the thoracolumbosacral orthosis (TLSO), indicated brace wearing for a mean of 20.6 h daily. Regarding bracing discontinuation, indicated gradual brace weaning, a decision 93.9% based on anterior-posterior (AP) and lateral radiographs of the spine and physical examination, considered a Risser ≥ IV and ≥ 24 months post menarche.
The results of this study provide insight in the daily practice of spine surgeons regarding how and when they discontinue bracing in AIS. The decision of bracing discontinuation is based on AP/lateral spinal radiographs and physical examination, Risser ≥ IV, regardless of Tanner stage, and ≥ 24 months post menarche. Gradual weaning is recommended.
目前,对于青少年特发性脊柱侧凸(AIS)患者如何或何时停止使用支具,几乎没有达成共识。一项针对脊柱外科专家的全国性调查可能有助于阐明支具停用的问题。关于AIS患者何时以及如何停止支具治疗的数据很少,这导致了该病管理方式的差异。本研究的目的是描述脊柱外科医生在AIS支具停用管理中的决策过程。
向国家脊柱外科学会的所有成员(共调查497人)发送了一份包含12个多项选择题的原始电子调查问卷。参与者被问及他们的医疗实践类型、在该领域的经验年限、学会会员身份、他们通常开具的支具类型、他们建议的每日平均支具佩戴时间,以及他们如何以及何时指示停止使用支具,以及做出该决定所基于的临床和/或影像学检查结果。排除标准包括因出现需要手术治疗的侧弯而停用支具的情况。
在总共497名外科医生中,114人回复了调查(22.9%)。71.9%的人在该专业领域有超过5年的经验,51%的人主要治疗儿科患者。总体而言,95.5%的外科医生开具胸腰骶矫形器(TLSO),指示平均每日佩戴支具20.6小时。关于支具停用,指示逐渐减少支具使用,93.9%的决定基于脊柱的前后位(AP)和侧位X线片以及体格检查,认为Risser分级≥IV级且月经初潮后≥24个月。
本研究结果为脊柱外科医生在AIS患者中如何以及何时停止使用支具的日常实践提供了见解。支具停用的决定基于脊柱AP/侧位X线片和体格检查、Risser分级≥IV级,无论坦纳分期如何,以及月经初潮后≥24个月。建议逐渐减少使用支具。