Departamento de Psicología Básica I, UNED, Spain.
Department of Psychology, University of Turku, Finland; Turku Brain and Mind Centre, University of Turku, Finland.
Neuropsychologia. 2018 Dec;121:144-152. doi: 10.1016/j.neuropsychologia.2018.11.001. Epub 2018 Nov 5.
A crucial view in the graded vs. dichotomous debate on visual awareness proposes that its graded or dichotomous nature may depend on the depth of stimulus processing (or level of processing) associated to the experimental task. In the present study, we explored the behavioral patterns and neural correlates of different degrees of awareness associated to different depths (i.e. low vs. high) of stimulus processing. The low-level stimulus condition consisted of detecting the location of the target based on its brightness characteristics, whereas the high-level stimulus condition consisted of identifying which of four possible targets (numbers/letters) had appeared. Behavioral results showed that both subjective ratings of awareness and accuracy levels increased linearly as a function of awareness and independently of the level of stimulus processing. Additionally, the electrophysiological recordings revealed two correlates of visual awareness: enhanced posterior negativity in the N200 time window (VAN, visual awareness negativity) and enhanced positivity in the P3 time window (LP, late positivity). Interestingly, we found evidence of awareness levels modulating N200/VAN amplitudes in a graded manner only for the low-level task, whereas P3/LP amplitudes were modulated in a graded manner for both low and high-level tasks. The finding that the early posterior correlate of visual awareness (VAN at 150-250 ms) was sensitive to level of processing is consistent with task effects occurring in the visual cortex and supports the view that it is mediated by attention to task-relevant features. The amplitudes of P3/LP in both tasks correlate more directly with graded awareness and behavioral accuracy.
在视觉意识的渐变与二分争论中,一个关键观点认为其渐变或二分性质可能取决于与实验任务相关的刺激处理深度(或处理水平)。在本研究中,我们探索了与不同深度(即低水平与高水平)刺激处理相关的不同程度意识的行为模式和神经相关性。低水平刺激条件包括基于目标亮度特征检测目标的位置,而高水平刺激条件包括识别四个可能目标(数字/字母)中的哪一个出现了。行为结果表明,意识的主观评分和准确性水平都随着意识的增加而呈线性增加,并且与刺激处理水平无关。此外,电生理记录揭示了视觉意识的两个相关因素:在 N200 时间窗口(VAN,视觉意识负波)中增强的后向负性和在 P3 时间窗口(LP,晚期正性)中增强的正性。有趣的是,我们发现仅在低水平任务中,意识水平以渐变方式调节 N200/VAN 振幅的证据,而 P3/LP 振幅在低水平和高水平任务中均以渐变方式调节。视觉意识的早期后向相关物(150-250ms 时的 VAN)对处理水平敏感的发现与视觉皮层中发生的任务效应一致,并支持其由对任务相关特征的注意力介导的观点。两个任务中的 P3/LP 振幅与渐变意识和行为准确性更直接相关。