Centre for Complex Trauma, Defence Medical Rehabilitation Centre Headley Court, Surrey, UK
School of Healthcare Sciences, Arthritis Research UK Biomechanics and Bioengineering Centre, Cardiff University, Cardiff, UK.
BMJ Mil Health. 2020 Jun;166(3):146-150. doi: 10.1136/jramc-2018-001001. Epub 2018 Nov 14.
Up to 70 % of military amputees suffer phantom limb pain (PLP), which is difficult to treat. PLP has been attributed to cortical reorganisation and associated with impaired laterality. Repeated sessions of mirror therapy (MT) can benefit PLP; however, anecdotal evidence suggests one MT session could be effective. In a one-group pretest and post-test design, 16 UK military unilateral lower limb amputees (median age: 31.0, 95% CI 25.0 to 36.8 years) undertook one 10 min MT session. Visual analogue scale (VAS) pain and laterality (accuracy and reaction time) measurements were taken pre-MT and post-MT. Median VAS PLP did not differ significantly between pre-MT 15 mm (2-53 mm) and post-MT 12 mm (1-31) (p=0.875) scores. For the amputated limb, there were no significant differences between pre-MT and post-MT scores for laterality accuracy, 95.3%, 95% CI 90.5% to 97.6% and 96.7%, 95% CI 90.0% to 99.4%, respectively (p=0.778), or reaction time, 1.42 s, 95% CI 1.11 to 2.11 s and 1.42 s, 95% CI 1.08 to 2.02 s, respectively (p=0.629). Laterality was also not different between limbs for accuracy, p=0.484, or reaction time, p=0.716, and did not correlate with PLP severity. No confounding variables predicted individual responses to MT. Therefore, one 10 min MT session does not affect laterality and is not effective as standard treatment for PLP in military lower limb amputees. However, substantial PLP improvement for one individual and resolution of a stuck phantom limb for another infers that MT may benefit specific patients. No correlation found between PLP and laterality implies associated cortical reorganisation may not be the main driver for PLP. Further research, including neuroimaging, is needed to help clinicians effectively target PLP.
高达 70%的军事截肢者患有幻肢痛(PLP),这种疼痛难以治疗。PLP 归因于皮质重组,并与侧性受损相关。重复进行镜像治疗(MT)可以改善 PLP;然而,传闻证据表明单次 MT 治疗可能有效。在一项单组预测试和后测试设计中,16 名英国军事单侧下肢截肢者(中位数年龄:31.0,95%CI 25.0 至 36.8 岁)进行了一次 10 分钟的 MT 治疗。在 MT 之前和之后测量视觉模拟量表(VAS)疼痛和侧性(准确性和反应时间)测量值。MT 前的 VAS PLP 中位数为 15mm(2-53mm),MT 后为 12mm(1-31mm),差异无统计学意义(p=0.875)。对于截肢肢体,MT 前和 MT 后侧性准确性的评分无显著差异,分别为 95.3%,95%CI 90.5%至 97.6%和 96.7%,95%CI 90.0%至 99.4%(p=0.778),反应时间也无显著差异,分别为 1.42s,95%CI 1.11 至 2.11s 和 1.42s,95%CI 1.08 至 2.02s(p=0.629)。肢体之间的侧性也没有差异,无论是准确性,p=0.484,还是反应时间,p=0.716,并且与 PLP 严重程度无关。没有混杂变量可以预测 MT 对个体的反应。因此,单次 10 分钟 MT 治疗不会影响侧性,也不是军事下肢截肢者 PLP 的标准治疗方法。然而,对于一个个体来说,PLP 有明显的改善,对于另一个个体来说,幻肢有了明显的缓解,这表明 MT 可能对特定的患者有益。PLP 与侧性之间没有相关性表明,相关的皮质重组可能不是 PLP 的主要驱动因素。需要进一步的研究,包括神经影像学,以帮助临床医生有效地针对 PLP。