Witchel Harry J, Guppy Joseph H, Smith Claire F
Brighton and Sussex Medical School , Brighton , United Kingdom.
Adv Physiol Educ. 2018 Dec 1;42(4):697-703. doi: 10.1152/advan.00081.2018.
Student self-assessment using computer-based quizzes has been shown to increase subject memory and engagement. Some types of self-assessment quizzes can be associated with a dilemma between 1) medical students who want the self-assessment quiz to be clearly related to upcoming summative assessments or curated by the exam-setters, and 2) university administrators and ethics committees who want clear guarantees that the self-assessment quizzes are not based on the summative assessments or made by instructors familiar with the exam bank of items. An algorithm in Matlab was developed to formulate multiple-choice questions for both ion transport proteins and pharmacology. A resulting question/item subset was uploaded to the Synap online self-quiz web platform, and 48 year 1 medical students engaged with it for 3 wk. Anonymized engagement statistics for students were provided by the Synap platform, and a paper-based exit questionnaire with an 80% response rate ( n = 44) measured satisfaction. Four times as many students accessed the quiz system via laptop compared with phone/tablet. Of 391 questions/items, over 11,749 attempts were made. Greater than 80% of respondents agreed with each of the positive statements (ease of use, enjoyed, engaged more, learned more, and wanted it to be extended to other modules). Despite simplistic questions and rote memorization, the questions developed by this system were engaged with and were received positively. Students strongly supported extending the system.
使用基于计算机的测验进行学生自我评估已被证明可以增强学科记忆和参与度。某些类型的自我评估测验可能会在以下两者之间产生两难困境:一是希望自我评估测验与即将到来的总结性评估明确相关或由出题者精心策划的医学生,二是希望得到明确保证,即自我评估测验不是基于总结性评估或由熟悉试题库的教师编写的大学管理人员和伦理委员会。开发了一种Matlab算法来为离子转运蛋白和药理学制定多项选择题。将生成的问题/项目子集上传到Synap在线自我测验网络平台,48名一年级医学生参与了3周。Synap平台提供了学生的匿名参与统计数据,并通过一份纸质的退场调查问卷(回复率为80%,n = 44)来衡量满意度。通过笔记本电脑访问测验系统的学生人数是通过手机/平板电脑访问的四倍。在391个问题/项目中,进行了超过11749次尝试。超过80%的受访者同意每一项积极陈述(易用性、喜欢、参与度更高、学到更多以及希望将其扩展到其他模块)。尽管问题简单且需要死记硬背,但该系统开发的问题仍受到关注并得到积极反馈。学生们强烈支持扩展该系统。