Whiston Hospital, Warrington Road, Prescot, Liverpool, L35 5DR, UK.
Department of Emergency Medicine, Aga Khan University, P O Box 3500, Stadium Road, Karachi, Pakistan.
Child Abuse Negl. 2019 Feb;88:51-57. doi: 10.1016/j.chiabu.2018.10.008. Epub 2018 Nov 14.
Child abuse is a global problem and pervades all cultures and socio-economic strata. The effects can be profound and life altering for victims. There is substantial literature from high income countries about signs of abuse, but a dearth of data from low and middle income countries like Pakistan. Healthcare professionals (HCP) are ideally placed to detect abuse, but, to inform interventions, an understanding of their experiences, training needs and cultural beliefs is needed. This study aimed to: (1) Explore the challenges that HCP face when managing cases of abuse; (2) Explore cultural beliefs and understand how these shape practice and (3) Identify training needs. A qualitative study using a phenomenological design was conducted. In-depth interviews were conducted with doctors, nurses and security staff in the emergency department of a large private hospital in Pakistan (n = 15). Interviews were undertaken in Urdu, translated into English and analysed using an inductive thematic approach. Multiple challenges were identified. The process of referral to legal services was poorly understood and further training and guidelines was suggested by participants. As the legal system in Pakistan does not allow HCP to keep potentially abused patients in their custody, they felt restricted in their ability to advocate and concerned about the safety of both the identified children and themselves. HCP have potential to detect abuse early; however, in Pakistan there are numerous challenges. HCP require support through training, as well as clear institutional frameworks and legal support to undertake this role.
儿童虐待是一个全球性问题,存在于所有文化和社会经济阶层。对受害者来说,其影响可能是深远的、改变生活的。高收入国家有大量关于虐待迹象的文献,但像巴基斯坦这样的低收入和中等收入国家的数据却很少。医疗保健专业人员(HCP)是发现虐待行为的理想人选,但为了进行干预,需要了解他们的经验、培训需求和文化信仰。本研究旨在:(1)探讨 HCP 在处理虐待案件时面临的挑战;(2)探讨文化信仰,了解这些信仰如何影响实践;(3)确定培训需求。本研究采用现象学设计进行了一项定性研究。在巴基斯坦一家大型私立医院的急诊室,对医生、护士和保安进行了深入访谈(n=15)。访谈以乌尔都语进行,翻译成英语,并采用归纳主题方法进行分析。确定了多个挑战。向法律服务机构转介的过程理解不充分,参与者建议进一步培训和制定指南。由于巴基斯坦的法律体系不允许 HCP 拘留可能被虐待的患者,他们感到自己在倡导方面的能力受到限制,并担心被识别出的儿童和自己的安全。HCP 有潜力尽早发现虐待行为;然而,在巴基斯坦存在许多挑战。HCP 需要通过培训获得支持,以及明确的机构框架和法律支持来履行这一角色。