Lam Larry, Ansari Armaan S, Baquir Patrick J, Chowdhury Naziha, Tran Kelvin, Bailey Jannine
Bathurst Rural Clinical School, Western Sydney University, PO Box 9008, Bathurst, NSW 2795, Australia
Rural Remote Health. 2018 Nov;18(4):4714. doi: 10.22605/RRH4714. Epub 2018 Nov 19.
Advance care planning (ACP) and advance care directives (ACDs) play a vital role in preparing for end-of-life care. However, current literature suggests that uptake of ACP and ACDs in rural Australia is low, which may contribute to lower quality care for the older rural population, as patients' end-of-life wishes may not be recognised and acknowledged. This study aims to provide a current perspective on the attitudes and practices of healthcare workers from residential aged care facilities towards ACP and ACDs in the central west, far west and Orana regions of New South Wales, Australia.
This was a mixed-methods study incorporating anonymous survey and individual interviews. Healthcare workers from 12 residential aged care facilities within the studied region completed surveys (n=109). The 40-item survey assessed participant demographics, training and experience with ACP and ACD, attitudes towards ACP and ACDs, and barriers and facilitators towards the use of ACP and ACDs in their organisation. Five participants were interviewed to explore these issues in more depth.
Almost three-quarters (71%) of respondents thought that ACP is necessary while almost half (48%) were involved with >5 ACDs in the past 12 months. Formal training was seen as beneficial by most (81%) but the importance of practical experience was also acknowledged. No statistically significant differences were found in attitudes between those with 5 years of experience. Avoidance of unnecessary resuscitation was a consistent theme in all interviews and the potential of a nurse-led model of delivery was identified. Patient factors such as decreased capacity to make informed decisions were identified as barriers that could be circumvented by pre-emptive implementation of ACP discussion. The rural setting was identified as a facilitator due to a supportive community, which helped to mitigate barriers such as limited staffing.
Attitudes towards ACP in rural New South Wales are highly positive. The rural setting is a facilitator to ACP, and ACDs are approached in a multidisciplinary fashion. Further training is an identified need although on-the-ground experience may be more beneficial.
预先护理计划(ACP)和预先护理指示(ACD)在临终护理准备中起着至关重要的作用。然而,目前的文献表明,澳大利亚农村地区对ACP和ACD的接受程度较低,这可能导致农村老年人口的护理质量下降,因为患者的临终愿望可能未得到认可和重视。本研究旨在提供关于澳大利亚新南威尔士州中西部、远西部和奥拉纳地区老年护理机构医护人员对ACP和ACD的态度及实践的当前观点。
这是一项采用匿名调查和个人访谈相结合的混合方法研究。研究区域内12家老年护理机构的医护人员完成了调查(n = 109)。这份包含40个条目的调查问卷评估了参与者的人口统计学特征、ACP和ACD方面的培训及经验、对ACP和ACD的态度,以及在其所在机构使用ACP和ACD的障碍与促进因素。对5名参与者进行了访谈以更深入地探讨这些问题。
近四分之三(71%)的受访者认为ACP是必要的,近一半(48%)的受访者在过去12个月中参与了超过5份ACD。大多数人(81%)认为正规培训有益,但实践经验的重要性也得到了认可。在有5年工作经验的人员之间,态度上未发现统计学显著差异。避免不必要的复苏是所有访谈中的一个一致主题,并且确定了由护士主导的实施模式的潜力。患者因素,如做出明智决策的能力下降,被确定为障碍,可通过提前开展ACP讨论来规避。农村环境被确定为一个促进因素,因为社区支持有助于缓解人员配备有限等障碍。
新南威尔士州农村地区对ACP的态度非常积极。农村环境是ACP的一个促进因素,并且以多学科方式处理ACD。尽管实地经验可能更有益,但仍确定需要进一步培训。