Department of Human Development & Family Studies, Iowa State University, United States of America.
Early Childhood Education Institute, University of Oklahoma-Tulsa, United States of America.
J Sch Psychol. 2018 Dec;71:1-17. doi: 10.1016/j.jsp.2018.10.002. Epub 2018 Oct 29.
Using data from a large study of 78 high-quality Head Start classrooms in 12 sites across the U.S., this study examined whether peers' receptive vocabulary skills and teacher-reported social-emotional (S-E) functioning (i.e., behavior problems and self-regulation) measured at the beginning of the preschool year were related to children's gains in these three domains over a school year. Analyses included over 75% of the children in each classroom and produced three noteworthy findings. First, children in classrooms where average peers had higher behavior problems demonstrated increased teacher-reported behavior problems themselves at the end of the year. Second, children in classrooms where average peers had higher self-regulation skills demonstrated larger gains in teacher-reported self-regulation skills at the end of the school year. Third, peers' higher baseline self-regulation skills were found to be associated with children's higher self-regulation in spring, especially when children began the school year with higher levels of self-regulation. This finding indicates that children who have higher baseline self-regulation may be better positioned to benefit from their peers' high self-regulation in developing their own self-regulation skills. In contrast, no evidence was found that peers' baseline receptive vocabulary skills were related to children's receptive vocabulary gains over a school year. Additionally, no significant cross-domain peer effects were found between peers' baseline S-E functioning and children's receptive vocabulary gains nor peers' baseline receptive vocabulary skills and children's S-E development over a school year. Implications of these findings for classroom practice and further research are discussed.
本研究使用了来自美国 12 个地点的 78 个高质量 Head Start 教室的大型研究数据,考察了在学前教育年度之初,同伴的接受性词汇技能和教师报告的社会情感(S-E)功能(即行为问题和自我调节)是否与儿童在这三个领域的全年收益相关。分析包括每个教室超过 75%的儿童,并产生了三个值得注意的发现。首先,在同伴行为问题较高的教室中,儿童自身在年末表现出更多的教师报告行为问题。其次,在同伴自我调节技能较高的教室中,儿童在学年结束时教师报告的自我调节技能有更大的提高。第三,发现同伴较高的基线自我调节技能与儿童在春季的较高自我调节技能有关,尤其是当儿童开始学年时自我调节技能较高时。这一发现表明,自我调节技能较高的儿童可能更有能力从同伴较高的自我调节技能中受益,从而发展自己的自我调节技能。相比之下,没有证据表明同伴的基线接受性词汇技能与儿童在学年内的接受性词汇收益有关。此外,在学年内,同伴的基线 S-E 功能与儿童的接受性词汇收益之间,以及同伴的基线接受性词汇技能与儿童的 S-E 发展之间,都没有发现显著的跨领域同伴效应。这些发现对课堂实践和进一步研究的意义进行了讨论。