Walker P L, Johnson J R, Lambert P M
Department of Anthropology, University of California, Santa Barbara 93106.
Am J Phys Anthropol. 1988 Jun;76(2):183-8. doi: 10.1002/ajpa.1330760206.
Inaccuracies introduced through biases in preservation are a major source of error in paleodemographic reconstructions. Although it is generally assumed that such biases exist, little is known about their magnitude. To investigate this problem, we studied age and sex differences in the preservation of skeletal remains from Mission La Purisima and a prehistoric cemetery (Ca-Ven-110). Comparison of mortality profiles obtained through analysis of skeletal remains and burial records from the mission indicates that biases in preservation can be very significant in poorly preserved skeletal collections. The Purisima burial records show that most of the people interred in the cemetery were either infants or elderly adults. The skeletal remains, in contrast, are predominantly those of young adults. The burial records and skeletal collection produced comparable sex ratios. These results show that age biases in preservation are much more important than sex biases. This conclusion is supported by data on the completeness of the skeletons from La Purisima and Ca-Ven-110. At both sites, the remains of young adults were better preserved than those of children or elderly adults, and the completeness of male and female skeletons was comparable.
保存过程中的偏差所导致的不准确是古人口统计学重建中误差的一个主要来源。尽管人们普遍认为存在这样的偏差,但对其程度却知之甚少。为了研究这个问题,我们研究了拉普里西马传教区和一个史前墓地(Ca-Ven-110)骨骼遗骸保存方面的年龄和性别差异。通过对传教区骨骼遗骸和埋葬记录的分析得出的死亡率分布比较表明,在保存状况不佳的骨骼样本中,保存偏差可能非常显著。拉普里西马的埋葬记录显示,埋葬在该墓地的大多数人要么是婴儿,要么是老年人。相比之下,骨骼遗骸主要是年轻人的。埋葬记录和骨骼样本的性别比例相当。这些结果表明,保存过程中的年龄偏差比性别偏差重要得多。拉普里西马和Ca-Ven-110的骨骼完整性数据支持了这一结论。在这两个地点,年轻人的遗骸比儿童或老年人的遗骸保存得更好,而且男性和女性骨骼的完整性相当。