Division of Pediatric Urology, Department of Urology, Indiana University School of Medicine, Indianapolis, IN 46202, USA.
Division of Pediatric Urology, Department of Urology, Indiana University School of Medicine, Indianapolis, IN 46202, USA.
J Pediatr Urol. 2019 Feb;15(1):39.e1-39.e6. doi: 10.1016/j.jpurol.2018.10.010. Epub 2018 Oct 19.
Historically, there have been few treatment options for children with severe refractory bladder and bowel dysfunction (BBD). Sacral neuromodulation (SNM) continues to show promising results in this challenging pediatric population with recalcitrant lower urinary tract symptoms. At the authors institution, they have begun offering explantation to those with persistent improvement after >6 months of having device turned off. The authors hypothesized that (1) SNM explantation for cure increases with extended follow-up and (2) those explanted for cure would have improved symptoms and quality of life when compared to those explanted for complication.
MATERIALS & METHODS: The authors retrospectively reviewed all consecutive patients aged <18 years who underwent SNM placements at their institution (2012-2017). They excluded those without the second stage procedure. Reasons for device explantation were categorized as cure (resolution of symptoms with the device turned off for at least 6 months) or a complication (e.g. infection, need for magnetic resonance imaging, or pain). Non-parametric tests and survival analysis were used for analysis to account for differential follow-up time. Of those explanted, surveys were electronically sent to assess BBD severity and overall quality of life.
Of 67 children who underwent a first stage procedure, 62 (92.5%) underwent a second stage procedure. 61 met inclusion criteria (68.9% female, 29.5% with previous filum section, median age at implantation 10.3 years). During follow-up (median 2.3 years), 12 patients (19.7%) had the SNM exchanged/revised because of lead fracture/breakage and return of urinary symptoms. To date, 50 patients remain with their SNM implanted, and 11 have been explanted. Adjusting for follow-up time, the risk of explantation was 6.5% at 2 years (2.2% for cure, 4.3% for complications) (Figure 1). Explantation increased to 24.5% at 3 years (16.5% for cure, 8.0% for complications) and 40.4% at 4 years (32.4% for cure, 8.0% for complications). Questionnaires were collected on patients after explant (median 2.2 years), with improvement in those explanted for cure compared to complication (Figure 2).
Sacral neuromodulation explantation for cure is a novel concept previously not described in the literature. Limitations of this study include the relatively small numbers and lack of objective data in the cohort that remains with SNM device implanted.
Sacral neuromodulation is a safe, viable option for the pediatric patient with refractory bladder dysfunction. Furthermore, SNM explantation for cure is an option with increasing likelihood after 2 years.
历史上,对于严重难治性膀胱和肠道功能障碍(BBD)的儿童,治疗选择很少。骶神经调节(SNM)在具有顽固性下尿路症状的具有挑战性的儿科人群中继续显示出有希望的结果。在作者所在的机构,他们开始为那些在设备关闭后> 6 个月仍持续改善的患者提供摘除手术。作者假设:(1)SNM 摘除术的治愈率随随访时间的延长而增加;(2)与因并发症而进行摘除术的患者相比,因治愈而进行摘除术的患者的症状和生活质量会有所改善。
作者回顾性分析了在其机构(2012-2017 年)接受 SNM 放置的所有<18 岁的连续患者。他们排除了没有第二阶段手术的患者。设备摘除的原因分为治愈(设备关闭至少 6 个月后症状缓解)或并发症(例如感染,需要磁共振成像或疼痛)。使用非参数检验和生存分析来分析以考虑不同的随访时间。在那些接受了摘除手术的患者中,他们通过电子方式发送了调查,以评估 BBD 的严重程度和整体生活质量。
在接受第一阶段手术的 67 名儿童中,有 62 名(92.5%)接受了第二阶段手术。61 名符合纳入标准(68.9%为女性,29.5%有以前的悬丝节段,植入时的中位年龄为 10.3 岁)。在随访期间(中位 2.3 年),由于导联断裂/断裂和尿路症状的恢复,有 12 名患者(19.7%)接受了 SNM 交换/修正。迄今为止,有 50 名患者仍植入了 SNM,有 11 名患者已被摘除。考虑到随访时间,2 年内的摘除风险为 6.5%(2.2%为治愈,4.3%为并发症)(图 1)。在 3 年内,摘除率上升至 24.5%(16.5%为治愈,8.0%为并发症),在 4 年内上升至 40.4%(32.4%为治愈,8.0%为并发症)。在摘除后收集了患者的问卷(中位时间为 2.2 年),与因并发症而进行摘除术的患者相比,因治愈而进行摘除术的患者有改善(图 2)。
骶神经调节的治愈性摘除术是以前文献中未描述的新概念。本研究的局限性包括队列中剩余的带有 SNM 设备植入物的患者数量相对较少且缺乏客观数据。
骶神经调节是治疗难治性膀胱功能障碍的儿科患者的安全,可行的选择。此外,2 年后,治愈性摘除术的可能性越来越大。