Kobylańska Marzena, Kowalska Joanna, Neustein Jolanta, Mazurek Justyna, Wójcik Bartosz, Bełza Małgorzata, Cichosz Michał, Szczepańska-Gieracha Joanna
Department of Physiotherapy, University School of Physical Education, Wroclaw, Poland.
Department of Neurological Rehabilitation, Wroclaw Centre for Rehabilitation and Sports Medicine, Wroclaw, Poland.
Work. 2018;61(4):523-535. doi: 10.3233/WOR-162823.
A large proportion of individuals with a stroke are unable to return to work, although figures vary greatly. Due to the very high cost of post-stroke care, both tangible and intangible, in the form of long-term social consequences, it seems extremely important to search for factors responsible for the low efficiency of the rehabilitation and recovery process, because this fact has direct influence on future employment. Such knowledge would enable physiotherapists to quickly identify those patients who are at risk of rehabilitation breakdown, in order to provide them with special care and include them in intensive therapeutic treatments.
The aim of the study was to assess the efficacy of post-stroke rehabilitation, evaluated within the biopsychosocial aspect.
The study consisted of 120 patients after first stroke, including 48 women and 72 men aged 58.0 (±8.6). The measure of the effects of physiotherapy in the present study was not only the improvement of the functional state (simple and complex activities of daily life, locomotive activities), but also the improvement of the mental state (mood and the sense of well-being, level of acceptance of illness, perceived self-efficacy) and the reduction of pain. The Mini-Mental State Examination, the Geriatric Depression Scale, the Generalized Self-Efficacy Scale, the Acceptance of Illness Scale, the Visual Analogue Scale, the Barthel Index, the Instrumental Activity of Daily Living and the Rivermead Mobility Index were used. All parameters were measured twice: on admission to the ward and after three weeks of physiotherapy. The characteristics of the study group were presented using descriptive statistics. The analysis of interdependence of the efficacy of physiotherapy used two non-parametric tests: the Mann-Whitney U test to compare two groups, and the Kruskal-Wallis ANOVA test to compare a greater number of groups. Correlations between characteristics with continuous distributions were assessed using Spearman's rank correlation coefficient (ρ), and in case of categorical variables, Pearson's chi-squared (χ2) correlation coefficient. Linear regression was used to determine the hierarchy of the influence of particular characteristics on the efficacy of physiotherapy.
Statistical analyzes show that patient's age, time since stroke, number of comorbidities, family care capacity, marital status of the patient and also a low level of acceptance of illness, depression symptoms and lack of a sense of self-efficacy were related with low efficacy of post-stroke rehabilitationCONCLUSIONS:Comprehensive neurological rehabilitation, taking into account mental challenges and socio-economic circumstances of individuals with a stroke is essential in order to achieve high efficacy of physiotherapy. Important external factors may play a pivotal role in returning to work as well and should be taken into account during rehabilitation. Of interest should be to assess more biopsychological factors, such as acceptance of illness and a sense of self-efficacy referred to as barriers to return to work.
尽管数据差异很大,但很大一部分中风患者无法重返工作岗位。由于中风后护理成本极高,包括长期社会后果形式的有形和无形成本,寻找导致康复和恢复过程效率低下的因素显得极为重要,因为这一事实直接影响未来就业。此类知识将使物理治疗师能够迅速识别那些有康复失败风险的患者,以便为他们提供特殊护理并将他们纳入强化治疗。
本研究旨在评估中风后康复在生物心理社会层面的疗效。
本研究包括120例首次中风后的患者,其中48名女性和72名男性,年龄为58.0(±8.6)岁。本研究中物理治疗效果的衡量标准不仅包括功能状态的改善(日常生活的简单和复杂活动、运动活动),还包括心理状态的改善(情绪和幸福感、疾病接受程度、自我效能感)以及疼痛减轻。使用了简易精神状态检查表、老年抑郁量表、一般自我效能量表、疾病接受量表、视觉模拟量表、巴氏指数、日常生活活动能力量表和Rivermead运动指数。所有参数均测量两次:入院时和物理治疗三周后。使用描述性统计呈现研究组的特征。物理治疗效果的相关性分析使用了两种非参数检验:Mann-Whitney U检验用于比较两组,Kruskal-Wallis方差分析检验用于比较更多组。使用Spearman等级相关系数(ρ)评估具有连续分布的特征之间的相关性,对于分类变量,则使用Pearson卡方(χ2)相关系数。使用线性回归确定特定特征对物理治疗效果影响的层次结构。
统计分析表明,患者年龄、中风后的时间、合并症数量、家庭护理能力、患者婚姻状况以及疾病接受程度低、抑郁症状和缺乏自我效能感与中风后康复效果低相关。
为了实现物理治疗的高效性,综合考虑中风患者的心理挑战和社会经济状况的全面神经康复至关重要。重要的外部因素在重返工作岗位方面也可能发挥关键作用,在康复过程中应予以考虑。值得关注的是评估更多的生物心理因素,如疾病接受程度和自我效能感,这些被认为是重返工作岗位的障碍。