Laher M, Patel M
Clinical Haematology Unit, Department of Medicine and Faculty of Health Sciences, University of the Witwatersrand, South Africa.
Clinical Haematology Unit, Department of Medicine and Faculty of Health Sciences, University of the Witwatersrand, South Africa.
Transfus Apher Sci. 2019 Feb;58(1):43-47. doi: 10.1016/j.transci.2018.11.002. Epub 2018 Nov 16.
Rational and appropriate use of blood and blood products is important in a resource limited setting like South Africa. Proper education is required in decision-making and management with regard to blood transfusion. Status of the current knowledge of blood transfusion practice is also necessary in order to identify target areas of teaching and patient management.
To assess the knowledge regarding blood and blood products among doctors of varying ranks at the University of the Witwatersrand affiliated academic hospitals.
This is an observational, descriptive study using a self-administered questionnaire, comprising of 40 questions, equally divided into 6 sections covering different areas of transfusion medicine. Demographics of the participants and an opinion on how to impart further information was also included.
A response rate of 33% was obtained from the distributed questionnaires. After grouping medical professionals together, an average score of 61% was obtained. As individual groups, the consultants achieved the highest score of 64%, while the interns, who averaged 56%, achieved the lowest score. The medical officers and registrars averaged 63%, while community service doctors averaged 58%. Participants scored the best in the section pertaining to 'consent' averaging 87%. This was followed by 64%, achieved for the section regarding 'adverse effects'. The section regarding 'red blood cell usage' and 'blood product ordering' was scored at 60%, while the section on 'platelet usage' attained a score of 44%. The lowest score was achieved in the section regarding 'plasma product usage', 30%. A statistically significant gap in knowledge (p = 0.0139) was noted from intern up to medical officer level, after which the increase in knowledge up to consultant level was not found to be statistically significantly different.
The overall results obtained appear to be suboptimal and can be improved upon. Formalized and on-going teaching around blood and blood product usage is required at both undergraduate and postgraduate levels, to ensure that this scarce, but invaluable resource is used judiciously and appropriately.
在南非这样资源有限的环境中,合理且恰当地使用血液及血液制品至关重要。在输血的决策和管理方面需要进行适当的教育。了解当前输血实践的知识状况对于确定教学和患者管理的目标领域也很有必要。
评估威特沃特斯兰德大学附属学术医院不同职级医生对血液及血液制品的知识掌握情况。
这是一项观察性描述性研究,采用自填式问卷,问卷包含40个问题,平均分为6个部分,涵盖输血医学的不同领域。还包括参与者的人口统计学信息以及关于如何提供进一步信息的意见。
分发的问卷获得了33%的回复率。将医学专业人员归为一组后,平均得分为61%。作为个体组,顾问医生得分最高,为64%,而实习医生平均得分56%,是得分最低的。医务干事和住院医生平均得分63%,社区服务医生平均得分58%。参与者在“同意”部分得分最高,平均为87%。其次是“不良反应”部分,得分为64%。“红细胞使用”和“血液制品订购”部分得分为60%,而“血小板使用”部分得分为44%。得分最低的是“血浆制品使用”部分,为30%。从实习医生到医务干事级别,知识水平存在统计学上的显著差距(p = 0.0139),之后到顾问医生级别知识水平的提升未发现有统计学上的显著差异。
所获得的总体结果似乎并不理想,有待改进。本科和研究生阶段都需要围绕血液及血液制品的使用进行正规且持续的教学,以确保这种稀缺但宝贵的资源得到明智且恰当的使用。