Emergency Department, Regional Hospital West Jutland, Herning, Denmark.
Research Center for Emergency Medicine, Department of Clinical Medicine, Aarhus University, Palle Juul-Jensens Boulevard 99, Building J, Level 1 (J103), 8200, Aarhus N, Denmark.
J Digit Imaging. 2019 Oct;32(5):841-848. doi: 10.1007/s10278-018-0157-9.
Minor emergency departments (ED) struggle to access sufficient expertise to supervise learners of lung and cardiac point-of-care ultrasound (POCUS). Using tele-ultrasound (tele-US) for remote supervision may remedy this situation. We aimed to evaluate the feasibility of real-time supervision via tele-US when applied to an everyday ED clinic. We conducted a mixed methods study that assessed practical feasibility, determined performance, and explored users' acceptability of supervision via tele-US. Technical performance was assessed quantitatively by the ratio in mean gray value between images on site and as received by the supervisor, and by after-compression frame rate. Qualitatively, 12 exploratory semi-structured interviews were conducted with exposed junior doctors and supervisors. Remote supervision via tele-US was performed with 10 junior doctors scanning 45 included patients. During performance assessment, neither alternating internet connection nor software significantly changed the mean gray value ratio. The lowest median frame rate of 4.6 (interquartile range [IQR]: 3.1-5.0) was found by using a 4G internet connection; the highest of 28.5 (IQR: 28.5-29.0) was found with alternative computer and local area network internet connection. In interviews, supervisors stressed the importance of preserving frame rate, and junior doctors emphasized a need for shared ultrasound terminology. In the qualitative analysis, setup mobility, accessibility, and time consumption were emphasized as being of key importance for future clinical implementations. Remote supervision via a commercially available and low-cost tele-US setup is operational for both junior doctors and supervisors when applied to lung and cardiac POCUS scans of hospitalized patients.
小型急诊部(ED)难以获得足够的专业知识来监督肺部和心脏即时超声(POCUS)学习者。使用远程超声(tele-US)进行远程监督可能会改善这种情况。我们旨在评估将实时远程超声应用于日常 ED 诊所时的实际可行性。我们进行了一项混合方法研究,评估了通过 tele-US 进行实时监督的实际可行性、确定了性能,并探讨了用户对远程超声监督的可接受性。通过现场和主管接收的图像之间的平均灰度值比值以及压缩后帧率来定量评估技术性能。通过对 10 名扫描 45 名纳入患者的初级医生和主管进行 12 次探索性半结构式访谈,进行了定性评估。在性能评估期间,无论是交替的互联网连接还是软件都没有明显改变平均灰度值比值。使用 4G 互联网连接时,发现最低中位数帧率为 4.6(四分位距 [IQR]:3.1-5.0);使用替代计算机和局域网互联网连接时,发现最高帧率为 28.5(IQR:28.5-29.0)。在访谈中,主管强调了保持帧率的重要性,而初级医生则强调需要共享超声术语。在定性分析中,设置的移动性、可及性和时间消耗被强调为未来临床实施的关键重要性。当将其应用于住院患者的肺部和心脏即时 POCUS 扫描时,商业上可用且低成本的 tele-US 设置可用于初级医生和主管进行远程监督。