Department of Public Health Sciences, Health Informatics and Analytics Program, University of North Carolina at Charlotte, Charlotte, NC, United States of America.
School of Public Health, Faculty of Medicine, Imperial College London, London, United Kingdom.
PLoS One. 2018 Nov 28;13(11):e0207924. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0207924. eCollection 2018.
Increased interest about gun ownership and gun control are oftentimes driven by informational shocks in a common factor, namely violent attacks, and the perceived need for higher levels of safety. A causal depiction of the societal interest around violent attacks, gun control and gun purchase, both synchronous and over time, should be a stepping stone for designing future strategies regarding the safety concerns of the U.S. population.
Examine the causal relationships between unexpected increases in population interest about violent attacks, gun control, and gun purchase.
Relationships among online searches for information about violent attacks, gun control, and gun purchase occurring between 2004 and 2017 in the U.S. are explained through a novel structural vector autoregressive time series model to account for simultaneous causal relationships.
More than 20% of the stationary variability in each of gun control and gun purchase interest can be explained by the remaining factors. Gun control interest appears to be caused, in part, by violent attacks informational shocks, yet violent attacks, although impactful, have a lesser effect than gun control debate on long-term gun ownership interests.
The form in which gun control has been introduced in public debate may have further increased gun ownership interest. Reactive gun purchase interest may be an unintended side effect of gun control debate. U.S. policymakers may need to rethink current approaches to promotion of gun control, and whether societal policy debate without policy outcomes could be having unintended effects.
枪支拥有和枪支管制的兴趣增加通常是由共同因素引起的信息冲击驱动的,即暴力袭击,以及对更高安全水平的感知需求。对暴力袭击、枪支管制和枪支购买的社会利益进行同步和随时间变化的因果描述,应该是设计美国人口安全问题未来策略的垫脚石。
检验人口对暴力袭击、枪支管制和枪支购买的兴趣突然增加之间的因果关系。
通过一种新颖的结构向量自回归时间序列模型,解释了 2004 年至 2017 年期间美国发生的暴力袭击、枪支管制和枪支购买在线搜索信息之间的关系,以说明同时存在的因果关系。
枪支管制和枪支购买兴趣的稳定变化的 20%以上可以用其余因素来解释。枪支管制兴趣似乎部分是由暴力袭击信息冲击引起的,但尽管暴力袭击具有影响力,但对长期枪支拥有兴趣的影响小于枪支管制辩论。
枪支管制在公共辩论中引入的形式可能进一步增加了枪支拥有兴趣。对枪支的反应性购买兴趣可能是枪支管制辩论的一个意外副作用。美国政策制定者可能需要重新考虑当前促进枪支管制的方法,以及没有政策结果的社会政策辩论是否可能产生意想不到的影响。