Song Jin Hwa, Lee Chang-Hoon, Um Soo-Jung, Park Yong Bum, Yoo Kwang Ha, Jung Ki Suck, Lee Sang-Do, Oh Yon-Mok, Lee Ji Hyun, Kim Eun Kyung, Kim Deog Kyeom
Division of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine, Department of Internal Medicine, Seoul National University Hospital, Seoul, Republic of Korea.
Division of Respiratory Medicine, Department of Internal Medicine, Dong-A University College of Medicine, Dong-A University Medical Center, Busan, Republic of Korea.
Int J Chron Obstruct Pulmon Dis. 2018 Oct 23;13:3473-3484. doi: 10.2147/COPD.S177238. eCollection 2018.
While GOLD classification has been revised, its clinical impacts on outcomes of COPD patients have not been widely evaluated in real-world cohorts.
According to 2007, 2013, and 2017 GOLD classifications, distribution and clinical characteristics of group-shifted patients and the risk of acute exacerbation were analyzed in combined Korean COPD cohorts. Future risk for annual moderate-to-severe exacerbation was estimated as incidence rate ratio (IRR) and compared by groups.
Among 1,880 COPD patients, in GOLD 2017 classification, groups B and A were increased to 61.2% and 22.2% of total population, while group C was shrunken to 2.2% and patients with higher risk were decreased (16.6% in GOLD 2017 vs 44.7% in GOLD 2013). The kappa coefficient of agreement of both systems was 0.581 (agreement 71.7%). Groups B and D showed higher IRR of moderate-to-severe exacerbation than group A (IRR 2.4 and 5.3 respectively, <0.001), whereas group C was not different from group A. When groups C and D were combined, the IRR for acute exacerbation for each group showed good linear trends (2.5 [1.6-3.7] for group B and 4.8 [3.0-7.7] for combined group [C+D], <0.001).
In the revised GOLD 2017 system, COPD patients with higher risk were much decreased in Korean cohorts, and group C was negligible in size and clinical impacts on expecting future exacerbation. Serial increase in the risk for exacerbation was more concrete and predictable when group C was combined with group D.
虽然慢性阻塞性肺疾病全球倡议(GOLD)分类已修订,但其对慢性阻塞性肺疾病(COPD)患者预后的临床影响在真实世界队列中尚未得到广泛评估。
根据2007年、2013年和2017年GOLD分类,在合并的韩国COPD队列中分析组间转移患者的分布和临床特征以及急性加重风险。将年度中重度加重的未来风险估计为发病率比(IRR)并按组进行比较。
在1880例COPD患者中,在GOLD 2017分类中,B组和A组分别增至总人口的61.2%和22.2%,而C组缩减至2.2%,且高风险患者减少(GOLD 2017年为16.6%,GOLD 2013年为44.7%)。两种分类系统的kappa一致性系数为0.581(一致性为71.7%)。B组和D组中重度加重的IRR高于A组(分别为IRR 2.4和5.3,<0.001),而C组与A组无差异。当C组和D组合并时,每组急性加重的IRR呈现良好的线性趋势(B组为2.5 [1.6 - 3.7],合并组[C + D]为4.8 [3.0 - 7.7],<0.001)。
在修订后的GOLD 2017系统中,韩国队列中高风险的COPD患者大幅减少,C组在规模和对未来加重预期的临床影响方面可忽略不计。当C组与D组合并时,加重风险的连续增加更具体且可预测。