Smart R G
Addiction Research Foundation, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
J Stud Alcohol. 1988 Jul;49(4):314-23. doi: 10.15288/jsa.1988.49.314.
This article reviews the empirical warrant for the assertion that alcohol advertising affects overall alcohol consumption. Econometric, exposure, experimental studies and advertising bans are examined. The evidence indicates that advertising bans do not reduce alcohol sales, total advertising expenditures have no reliable correlation with sales of alcoholic beverages, and that experimental studies typically show no effect of advertising on actual consumption. However, one set of studies does show that drinkers are exposed to more television alcohol advertisements, without making the causal connection clear. In general, the evidence indicates little impact of alcohol advertising on alcohol sales or drinking. However, some results are suggestive and there is a need for more sophisticated econometric, exposure and experimental studies that take into account a wider range of variables.
本文回顾了关于酒精广告影响酒精总体消费量这一断言的实证依据。研究考察了计量经济学、曝光度、实验性研究以及广告禁令。证据表明,广告禁令并未减少酒精销量,广告总支出与酒精饮料销量之间不存在可靠的相关性,并且实验性研究通常表明广告对实际消费没有影响。然而,有一组研究确实表明饮酒者接触到更多的电视酒精广告,但未明确建立因果联系。总体而言,证据表明酒精广告对酒精销量或饮酒行为影响甚微。不过,一些结果具有启发性,需要开展更复杂的计量经济学、曝光度和实验性研究,以考虑更广泛的变量。