Shen Aolin, Wan Shengyun, Qian Bo, Ma Long, Yang Shuhan, Liu Biao, Zhang Lei, Shen Guodong
Depatment of General Surgery, the Second Affiliated Hospital of Anhui Medical University, Hefei 230031, China.
Depatment of General Surgery, the Second Affiliated Hospital of Anhui Medical University, Hefei 230031, China. Email:
Zhonghua Wei Chang Wai Ke Za Zhi. 2018 Nov 25;21(11):1268-1273.
To explore the application value of intraoperative ultrasound (IU) in laparoscopic lymphadenectomy of gastric cancer.
Patients with gastric cancer undergoing laparoscopic radical D2 gastrectomy at General Surgery of the Second Affiliated Hospital of Anhui Medical University between August 2016 and May 2018 were prospectively enrolled and were randomly divided into IU group (n=78) and conventional group (n=91). The conventional group underwent laparoscopy only. In IU group, the laparoscopy examination was followed with intraoperative ultrasound by ultrasound specialist. The lesser curvature, peripheral gastric organs and gastric lymph nodes were scanned. Lymph nodes were considered positive if maximum diameter was greater than 10 mm or internal hyperechoic features and normal oval shape were lost. The postoperative pathological results were used as the gold standard to analyze the sensitivity of positive lymph nodes by IU detection [true positive lymph nodes/(true positive lymph node+false negative lymph nodes)×100%], specificity [true negative lymph nodes/(true negative lymph nodes+false positive lymph nodes)×100%] and the accuracy rate[(true positive lymph nodes+ true negative lymph nodes/total lymph nodes)×100%]. A consistency check between N staging diagnosed by IU and by postoperative pathology was performed with Kappa test(Kappa>0.75 indicating good consistency). Number of dissected lymph node, number of positive lymph node detected by pathology and the operation time were compared between the IU group and the conventional group.
Among 169 gastric cancer patients, 95 were males and 74 were females with age of (63±8) years. Among 1 794 lymph nodes detected by IU from 78 patients in IU group, predicted positive lymph nodes were 832 and 740 positive nodes were confirmed by postoperative pathology. True positive lymph nodes were 679 and true negative lymph nodes were 901 by IU, and a total of 1 580 lymph nodes were accurately diagnosed by IU. The sensitivity and specificity of IU for N staging of gastric cancer were 91.8%(679/740) and 85.5%(901/1 054), respectively. Overall accuracy was 88.1%(1 580/1 794), which was in good accordance with postoperative N staging(Kappa=0.758). There was no significant difference in number of lymph node detected between the IU group and conventional group during laparoscopic gastric cancer surgery(23.0±6.9 vs. 22.0±7.7, t=0.880, P=0.380). However, the numbers of lymph nodes in the third station (No.10, No.11, No.12) in the IU group were significantly higher than those in the conventional group [No.10: median 1 (0-1) vs. 0 (0-1), Z=-6.307, P<0.001; No.11: median 1(0-2) vs. 0(0-1), Z=-5.895, P<0.001; No.12: median 1 (0-1) vs. 0 (0-1), Z=-6.693, P<0.001]. There was no significant difference in the number of positive lymph node between IU group and the conventional group(P>0.05), but the number of positive lymph nodes dissected in stage III patients of IU group was significantly higher than that in stage III patients of conventional group (14.6±4.8 vs. 14.0±3.6, t=2.531, P=0.011). The operative time of IU group was(272.0±12.0) minutes, which was significantly longer than (249.0±7.0) minutes of conventional group (t=14.638, P<0.001). However, with the increase of patients undergoing IU, the operation time of IU showed a downward trend. The average operation time of the last 20 patients was 264 minutes, and the average IU time was 15 minutes.
Intraoperative ultrasound is more accurate N-staging of gastric cancer. Although increasing operation time, it is helpful for lymph node dissection in laparoscopic gastric cancer surgery, especially by providing good support for laparoscopic No.10, No.11 and No.12 lymph nodes dissection.
探讨术中超声(IU)在胃癌腹腔镜淋巴结清扫术中的应用价值。
前瞻性纳入2016年8月至2018年5月在安徽医科大学第二附属医院普外科行腹腔镜根治性D2胃切除术的胃癌患者,随机分为IU组(n = 78)和传统组(n = 91)。传统组仅行腹腔镜检查。IU组在腹腔镜检查后由超声专科医生进行术中超声检查。扫描胃小弯、胃周围器官及胃淋巴结。若淋巴结最大直径大于10 mm或内部高回声特征及正常椭圆形消失,则认为该淋巴结为阳性。以术后病理结果作为金标准,分析IU检测阳性淋巴结的敏感度[真阳性淋巴结数/(真阳性淋巴结数 + 假阴性淋巴结数)×100%]、特异度[真阴性淋巴结数/(真阴性淋巴结数 + 假阳性淋巴结数)×100%]及准确率[(真阳性淋巴结数 + 真阴性淋巴结数/总淋巴结数)×100%]。采用Kappa检验对IU诊断的N分期与术后病理诊断的N分期进行一致性检验(Kappa>0.75表示一致性良好)。比较IU组和传统组的淋巴结清扫数目、病理检测阳性淋巴结数目及手术时间。
169例胃癌患者中,男性95例,女性74例,年龄(63±8)岁。IU组78例患者共检测1794枚淋巴结,预测阳性淋巴结832枚,术后病理确诊阳性淋巴结740枚。IU检测真阳性淋巴结679枚,真阴性淋巴结901枚,IU共准确诊断1580枚淋巴结。IU对胃癌N分期的敏感度和特异度分别为91.8%(679/740)和85.5%(901/1054)。总体准确率为88.1%(1580/1794),与术后N分期一致性良好(Kappa = 0.758)。腹腔镜胃癌手术中,IU组与传统组的淋巴结检出数目差异无统计学意义(23.0±6.9 vs. 22.0±7.7,t = 0.880,P = 0.380)。然而,IU组第3站(第10、11、12组)淋巴结数目显著高于传统组[第10组:中位数1(0 - 1)vs. 0(0 - 1),Z = -6.307,P < 0.001;第11组:中位数1(0 - 2)vs. 0(0 - 1),Z = -5.895,P < 0.001;第12组:中位数1(0 - 1)vs. 0(0 - 1),Z = -6.693,P < 0.001]。IU组与传统组的阳性淋巴结数目差异无统计学意义(P>0.05),但IU组Ⅲ期患者清扫的阳性淋巴结数目显著高于传统组Ⅲ期患者(14.6±4.8 vs. 14.0±3.6,t = 2.531,P = 0.011)。IU组手术时间为(272.0±12.0)分钟,显著长于传统组的(249.0±7.0)分钟(t = 14.638,P < 0.001)。然而,随着接受IU检查患者数量的增加,IU组的手术时间呈下降趋势。最后20例患者的平均手术时间为264分钟,平均IU时间为15分钟。
术中超声对胃癌N分期更准确。虽然增加了手术时间,但有助于腹腔镜胃癌手术中的淋巴结清扫,特别是为腹腔镜下第10、11和12组淋巴结清扫提供良好支持。