Health Services Research and Development, Durham Veterans Affairs Health Care System, Durham, North Carolina;
Department of Population Health Sciences.
J Am Soc Nephrol. 2019 Jan;30(1):159-168. doi: 10.1681/ASN.2018050521. Epub 2018 Dec 7.
Outcomes of veterans with ESRD may differ depending on where they receive dialysis and who finances this care, but little is known about variation in outcomes across different dialysis settings and financial arrangements.
We examined survival among 27,241 Veterans Affairs (VA)-enrolled veterans who initiated chronic dialysis in 2008-2011 at () VA-based units, () community-based clinics through the Veterans Affairs Purchased Care program (VA-PC), () community-based clinics under Medicare, or () more than one of these settings ("dual" care). Using a Cox proportional hazards model, we compared all-cause mortality across dialysis settings during the 2-year period after dialysis initiation, adjusting for demographic and clinical characteristics.
Overall, 4% of patients received dialysis in VA, 11% under VA-PC, 67% under Medicare, and 18% in dual settings (nearly half receiving dual VA and VA-PC dialysis). Crude 2-year mortality was 25% for veterans receiving dialysis in the VA, 30% under VA-PC, 42% under Medicare, and 23% in dual settings. After adjustment, dialysis patients in VA or in dual settings had significantly lower 2-year mortality than those under Medicare; mortality did not differ in VA-PC and Medicare dialysis settings.
Mortality rates were highest for veterans receiving dialysis in Medicare or VA-PC settings and lowest for veterans receiving dialysis in the VA or dual settings. These findings inform institutional decisions about provision of dialysis for veterans. Further research identifying processes associated with improved survival for patients receiving VA-based dialysis may be useful in establishing best practices for outsourced veteran care.
退伍军人终末期肾病(ESRD)的治疗结果可能因接受透析的地点和支付费用的机构而异,但对于不同透析环境和财务安排下结果的差异知之甚少。
我们对 2008 年至 2011 年期间在 VA 下属单位、通过 Veterans Affairs Purchased Care 计划(VA-PC)的社区诊所、医疗保险覆盖的社区诊所或以上这些环境中的两种或以上(“双重”护理)接受慢性透析的 27241 名 VA 登记退伍军人的生存情况进行了研究。采用 Cox 比例风险模型,我们比较了在透析开始后 2 年内不同透析环境的全因死亡率,并根据人口统计学和临床特征进行了调整。
总体而言,4%的患者在 VA 接受透析,11%在 VA-PC 下,67%在医疗保险下,18%在双重环境下(近一半在 VA 和 VA-PC 下接受双重透析)。退伍军人在 VA 接受透析的粗 2 年死亡率为 25%,在 VA-PC 下为 30%,在医疗保险下为 42%,在双重环境下为 23%。调整后,VA 或双重环境下的透析患者 2 年死亡率显著低于医疗保险下的患者;VA-PC 和医疗保险下的透析环境中死亡率没有差异。
在医疗保险或 VA-PC 环境下接受透析的退伍军人死亡率最高,而在 VA 或双重环境下接受透析的退伍军人死亡率最低。这些发现为退伍军人提供透析的机构决策提供了信息。进一步研究确定与 VA 透析患者生存改善相关的流程可能有助于为外包退伍军人护理制定最佳实践。