Rizzato Alex, Bosco Gerardo, Benazzato Michael, Paoli Antonio, Zorzetto Giulia, Carraro Attilio, Marcolin Giuseppe
Department of Biomedical Sciences, University of Padova, Padova, Italy.
Department of Industrial Engineering, University of Padova, Padova, Italy.
Front Physiol. 2018 Nov 26;9:1681. doi: 10.3389/fphys.2018.01681. eCollection 2018.
Postural balance control can be altered by land treadmill (LTM) running. This impairment seems to be related to a disturbance of vestibular and visual information. However, no studies are available on aquatic treadmill (ATM) running. The aim of the present study was to investigate the effect of running at moderate intensity over ATM and LTM on the postural balance control both with opened (OE) and closed (CE) eyes. Center of pressure (CoP) trajectory of 20 healthy subjects was collected on a dynamometric platform before and after a 20-min-long running on ATM and LTM at the same rate of perceived exertion (Borg's scale: 3/10). Heart rate (HR) was recorded every 30 s during running. Stabilogram diffusion analysis (SDA) and sample entropy (SampEn) were calculated to deepen motor control mechanisms. HR values were lower during ATM running with respect to LTM running ( < 0.01). A significant effect of the treadmill factor was detected in the OE condition for the sway path ( < 0.01; η = 0.364; Power: 0.879), the sway area ( < 0.01; η = 0.324; Power: 0.816), and the ML oscillations ( < 0.01; η = 0.390; Power: 0.911) while an effect of the time factor was detected for the ellipse area ( < 0.05; η = 0.213; Power: 0.576). However, the effect size for all the parameters ranged from 0.06 (trivial) to 0.48 (small). In the OE condition, the SDA highlighted a significant effect of the treadmill factor on all the short-term diffusion coefficients which negatively influenced the open loop motor control strategies. In the CE condition, SampEn analysis underlined a significant decrease of the CoP regularity after LTM running. Although slight modifications of the mechanisms involved in the postural balance control occurred, ATM and LTM moderate running did not seriously threaten postural balance performance. Therefore, the usage of ATM should be taken into account in all those situations where the well-known advantages of the aquatic environment are priorities.
陆地跑步机(LTM)跑步会改变姿势平衡控制。这种损害似乎与前庭和视觉信息的紊乱有关。然而,目前尚无关于水上跑步机(ATM)跑步的研究。本研究的目的是调查在ATM和LTM上以中等强度跑步对睁眼(OE)和闭眼(CE)时姿势平衡控制的影响。在20名健康受试者以相同的主观用力程度(Borg量表:3/10)在ATM和LTM上进行20分钟跑步前后,在测力平台上收集压力中心(CoP)轨迹。跑步期间每30秒记录一次心率(HR)。计算稳定图扩散分析(SDA)和样本熵(SampEn)以深入了解运动控制机制。与LTM跑步相比,ATM跑步期间的HR值更低(<0.01)。在OE条件下,对于摆动路径(<0.01;η=0.364;功效:0.879)、摆动面积(<0.01;η=0.324;功效:0.816)和ML振荡(<0.01;η=0.390;功效:0.911)检测到跑步机因素有显著影响,而对于椭圆面积检测到时间因素有影响(<0.05;η=0.213;功效:0.576)。然而,所有参数的效应大小范围从0.06(微不足道)到0.48(小)。在OE条件下,SDA突出显示跑步机因素对所有短期扩散系数有显著影响,这对开环运动控制策略产生负面影响。在CE条件下,SampEn分析强调LTM跑步后CoP规律性显著降低。尽管姿势平衡控制所涉及的机制发生了轻微改变,但ATM和LTM中等强度跑步并未严重威胁姿势平衡表现。因此,在所有将水环境的众所周知的优势作为优先考虑的情况下,都应考虑使用ATM。