Hill Neil E, Rilstone Sian, Stacey Michael J, Amiras Dimitri, Chew Stephen, Flatman David, Oliver Nick S
Department of Diabetes & Endocrinology, Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust, London, UK.
Diabetes Endocrinology and Metabolic Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, Imperial College London, St. Mary's Campus, London, UK.
BMJ Open Sport Exerc Med. 2018 Nov 16;4(1):e000459. doi: 10.1136/bmjsem-2018-000459. eCollection 2018.
We sought to establish the effects of professionalism, which officially began in 1995, on the body mass and height of northern hemisphere male international rugby union (RU) players. We hypothesised that mass would significantly increase following professionalism. We also investigated the changes in size of players according to their playing position, and we compared changes to rugby league (RL) players and the public.
The body mass and height of players representing their international team for that country's first game of the Five Nations in 1955, 1965, 1975, 1985 and 1995 and, for 2005 and 2015, the Six Nations, were collected from matchday programmes. RL players' data were collected from the Challenge Cup final games played in the same years.
International RU player body mass has significantly increased since 1995. In 1955 mean (±SD) player body mass was 84.8 kg (±8.2); in 2015, it was 105.4 kg (±12.1), an increase of 24.3%. Between 1955 and 2015, the body mass of forwards increased steadily, whereas that of backs has mostly gone up since 1995. RU player body mass gain has exceeded that of RL, but the age-matched difference between RU players and the public has remained relatively constant.
The factors influencing the gain in body mass of rugby players are legion; however, we believe that the interpretation of the law relating to the scrum put-in and changes allowing substitutions have, at least in part, contributed to the observed changes. Injury severity is increasing, and this may be linked to greater forces (caused by greater body mass) occurring in contact. RU law makers should adjust the rules to encourage speed and skill at the expense of mass.
我们试图确定1995年正式开始的职业化对北半球男性国际橄榄球联盟(RU)球员体重和身高的影响。我们假设职业化之后球员体重会显著增加。我们还研究了不同位置球员体型的变化,并将这些变化与橄榄球联盟(RL)球员及普通大众进行了比较。
从1955年、1965年、1975年、1985年和1995年该国参加五国赛首场比赛的国际代表队球员,以及2005年和2015年参加六国赛的球员的比赛日节目中收集其体重和身高数据。RL球员的数据则从同年举行的挑战杯决赛中收集。
自1995年以来,国际RU球员的体重显著增加。1955年球员平均体重(±标准差)为84.8千克(±8.2);2015年为105.4千克(±12.1),增长了24.3%。1955年至2015年期间,前锋的体重稳步增加,而后卫的体重大多自1995年起开始上升。RU球员体重的增加超过了RL球员,但RU球员与同年龄普通大众之间的差异保持相对稳定。
影响橄榄球运动员体重增加的因素众多;然而,我们认为与争球投进相关的规则解读以及允许换人规则的变化至少在一定程度上导致了上述变化。伤病严重程度在增加,这可能与接触时更大的力量(由更大的体重所致)有关。RU规则制定者应调整规则,以牺牲体重为代价来鼓励速度和技巧。