Stempel Christiane R, Rigotti Thomas
Work and Organizational Psychology, Medical School Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany.
Work, Organizational and Business Psychology, Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz, Mainz, Germany.
Front Psychol. 2018 Dec 5;9:2427. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2018.02427. eCollection 2018.
We investigated the role of gender in abusive leadership practices, along with the effects of abusive leadership on employee health. We tested two hypotheses regarding the relationship between abusive leadership practices and subordinates' health outcomes. At two points of measurement, 663 participants in Germany rated their 158 direct team leaders on abusive supervision and stated their own levels of emotional exhaustion and somatic stress. To test our hypotheses, we used a mixed model approach. The results show no gender differences between the ratings for female and male leaders regarding abusive supervision but do confirm that the leaders' gender did play a role in employees' perceptions of abuse; perceived abusive supervision is more strongly related to increased emotional exhaustion and somatic stress when the leader is male. The generalizability of the study is limited due to a majority of females in the sample. Organizations should review their policies and procedures to first identify abusive supervision, then to offer adequate support programs for both leaders and subordinates. The study integrates gender into research on leadership and health, shifting the focus from previous studies that investigated constructive to destructive leadership. A further strength of the study is the application of a multilevel design and two separate points of measurement.
我们研究了性别在虐待式领导行为中的作用,以及虐待式领导对员工健康的影响。我们检验了两个关于虐待式领导行为与下属健康结果之间关系的假设。在两个测量点,德国的663名参与者对他们的158名直接团队领导的虐待式监督进行了评分,并陈述了自己的情绪耗竭和躯体应激水平。为了检验我们的假设,我们采用了混合模型方法。结果显示,在虐待式监督方面,女性领导和男性领导的评分没有性别差异,但确实证实了领导的性别在员工对虐待行为的认知中起到了作用;当领导是男性时,感知到的虐待式监督与情绪耗竭和躯体应激增加的关联更强。由于样本中女性占多数,该研究的普遍性受到限制。组织应审查其政策和程序,首先识别虐待式监督,然后为领导和下属提供适当的支持项目。该研究将性别纳入领导与健康的研究中,将焦点从以往调查建设性领导转向了破坏性领导。该研究的另一个优势是应用了多层次设计和两个独立的测量点。