Bayes Sara, Juggins Elaine, Whitehead Lisa, De Leo Annemarie
Edith Cowan University, 270 Joondalup Drive, Joondalup, Western Australia 6027, Australia.
Midwifery. 2019 Mar;70:38-45. doi: 10.1016/j.midw.2018.12.012. Epub 2018 Dec 15.
The introduction of the best available evidence into health care practice is a complicated and uncertain process. Attempts to translate even highly reliable evidence into care provision are known to flounder. The objective of this study was to investigate midwives' experiences of leading practice change.
This study was conducted using Glaserian Grounded Theory methodology.
Australian midwifery practice contexts provided the setting for this study.
Midwives who had led practice change initiatives.
Sixteen Australian midwife change leaders participated in this study. Each had sought to implement a workplace practice change. The core problem experienced by the participants was labelled 'So many barriers on so many levels'.
Although some participants were encouraged, supported and enabled to enact change to some degree, even when the change was initiated by the practice site, all participants experienced a number of obstacles at many levels in their implementation efforts. For most, this meant that their endeavours to move the best available evidence into practice took many years or did not progress at all.
The findings of this study will be of interest to midwives, midwifery leaders and midwifery educators. Understanding the factors in midwifery care environments that support or limit the uptake of best evidence into practice will help to inform and develop midwifery context-specific mechanisms to expedite sustained practice innovation.
将最佳现有证据引入医疗保健实践是一个复杂且不确定的过程。即使是将高度可靠的证据转化为护理服务的尝试也往往会陷入困境。本研究的目的是调查助产士引领实践变革的经历。
本研究采用格拉斯哥扎根理论方法进行。
澳大利亚的助产实践环境为本研究提供了背景。
曾引领实践变革举措的助产士。
16位澳大利亚助产变革领导者参与了本研究。每位都曾试图在工作场所实施实践变革。参与者所经历的核心问题被标记为“诸多层面存在诸多障碍”。
尽管一些参与者在一定程度上受到鼓励、支持并能够实施变革,即使变革是由实践场所发起的,但所有参与者在实施过程中都在多个层面遇到了一些障碍。对大多数人来说,这意味着他们将最佳现有证据转化为实践的努力耗时多年,或者根本没有进展。
本研究结果将引起助产士、助产领导人和助产教育工作者的兴趣。了解助产护理环境中支持或限制将最佳证据应用于实践的因素,将有助于为制定和开发特定于助产环境的机制提供信息,以加快持续的实践创新。