Gillman Toby, Schmidtke Kelly Ann, Manning Victoria, Vlaev Ivo
Centre for Health Policy, Imperial College London, London, UK.
Warwick Business School, University of Warwick, Coventry, UK.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2018 Dec 27;18(1):998. doi: 10.1186/s12913-018-3799-x.
Musculoskeletal problems substantially impact the demand for and the finances of the United Kingdom's National Health Service. Some of this demand and cost could be alleviated if patients use self-directed-exercises. The present study aims first to establish whether general practitioners already recommend self-directed-exercises and second to describe barriers and facilitators to making such recommendations.
The design of the current study included surveys and interviews. The surveys were designed to draw out participants' tendency to recommend self-directed-exercises and their behavioral drivers to do so. The drivers investigated include 14 domains described by the Theoretical Domains Framework. The surveys were completed online and the responses were analyzed using descriptive reports and regression analyses. The interviews were designed to more fully understand participants' experiences recommending self-directed-exercises according to the same framework. The interviews were audio-taped, transcribed, and thematically analyzed.
The survey found that the following domains significantly predicted participants' tendency to recommend self-directed-exercises: Environmental contexts and resources, Goals, Intentions, Knowledge, Memory attention and decision processes, and Social/professional role. The interviews brought out four themes that could be leveraged to increase general practitioners' tendency to recommend self-directed-exercises: (1) Practitioners' beliefs about self-directed-exercises being effective, (2) Patients' motivations to engage in self-directed-exercises, (3) Time constraints, and (4) The ease with which practitioners can recommend self-directed-exercises.
Most general practitioners already recommend self-directed-exercises, though they note significant barriers that may prevent them from doing so. General practitioners' tendency to recommend self-directed-exercises would be bolstered by creating a respected central resource of exercise pamphlets. These pamphlets should clearly describe how different self-directed-exercises should be performed and evidence supporting their effectiveness.
肌肉骨骼问题对英国国家医疗服务体系的需求和财政状况产生了重大影响。如果患者进行自我指导锻炼,部分需求和成本可能会得到缓解。本研究旨在首先确定全科医生是否已经推荐自我指导锻炼,其次描述做出此类推荐的障碍和促进因素。
本研究的设计包括调查和访谈。调查旨在了解参与者推荐自我指导锻炼的倾向及其行为驱动因素。所调查的驱动因素包括理论领域框架描述的14个领域。调查通过在线完成,使用描述性报告和回归分析对回复进行分析。访谈旨在根据相同框架更全面地了解参与者推荐自我指导锻炼的经历。访谈进行了录音、转录并进行了主题分析。
调查发现,以下领域显著预测了参与者推荐自我指导锻炼的倾向:环境背景和资源、目标、意图、知识、记忆注意力和决策过程以及社会/职业角色。访谈揭示了四个可用于提高全科医生推荐自我指导锻炼倾向的主题:(1)从业者对自我指导锻炼有效性的信念,(2)患者参与自我指导锻炼的动机,(3)时间限制,以及(4)从业者推荐自我指导锻炼的难易程度。
大多数全科医生已经推荐自我指导锻炼,尽管他们指出了可能阻碍他们这样做的重大障碍。创建一个受人尊敬的锻炼手册中央资源将增强全科医生推荐自我指导锻炼的倾向。这些手册应清楚地描述不同的自我指导锻炼应如何进行以及支持其有效性的证据。