Hwang Sel-Ae, Lee Jae-Seo, Hwang Hyeon-Shik, Lee Kyung-Min
Department of Orthodontics, School of Dentistry, Chonnam National University, Gwangju, Korea.
Department of Oral Radiology, School of Dentistry, Chonnam National University, Gwangju, Korea.
Korean J Orthod. 2019 Jan;49(1):32-40. doi: 10.4041/kjod.2019.49.1.32. Epub 2018 Dec 19.
Precise identification of landmarks on posteroanterior (PA) cephalograms is necessary when evaluating lateral problems such as facial asymmetry. The aim of the present study was to investigate whether the use of lateral (LA) cephalograms can reduce errors in landmark identification on PA cephalograms.
Five examiners identified 16 landmarks (Cg, N, ANS, GT, Me, RO, Lo, FM, Z, Or, Zyg, Cd, NC, Ms, M, and Ag) on 32 PA cephalograms with and without LA cephalograms at the same time. The positions of the landmarks were recorded and saved in the horizontal and vertical direction. The mean errors and standard deviation of landmarks location according to the use of LA cephalograms were compared for each landmark.
Relatively small errors were found for ANS, Me, Ms, and Ag, while relatively large errors were found for N, GT, Z, Or, and Cd. No significant difference was found between the horizontal and vertical errors for Z and Or, while large vertical errors were found for N, GT, and Cd. The value of identification error was lower when the landmarks were identified using LA cephalograms. Statistically significant error reductions were found at N and Cd with LA cephalograms, especially in the vertical direction.
The use of LA cephalograms during identification of landmarks on PA cephalograms could help reduce identification errors.
在评估诸如面部不对称等侧方问题时,准确识别后前位(PA)头颅侧位片上的标志点是必要的。本研究的目的是调查使用侧位(LA)头颅侧位片是否能减少PA头颅侧位片上标志点识别的误差。
五名检查者同时在32张有和没有LA头颅侧位片的PA头颅侧位片上识别16个标志点(Cg、N、ANS、GT、Me、RO、Lo、FM、Z、Or、Zyg、Cd、NC、Ms、M和Ag)。记录标志点的位置并在水平和垂直方向上保存。比较每个标志点根据LA头颅侧位片使用情况的标志点位置平均误差和标准差。
ANS、Me、Ms和Ag的误差相对较小,而N、GT、Z、Or和Cd的误差相对较大。Z和Or的水平误差和垂直误差之间没有显著差异,而N、GT和Cd的垂直误差较大。使用LA头颅侧位片识别标志点时,识别误差值较低。使用LA头颅侧位片时,N和Cd的误差有统计学意义的降低,尤其是在垂直方向。
在PA头颅侧位片上识别标志点时使用LA头颅侧位片有助于减少识别误差。