Hamilton David, Bugg Ian
Critical Care, Northern Care Alliance, Manchester, UK.
Masanga Medical Research Unit, Masanga Hospital, Tonkolili District, Sierra Leone.
BMJ Open Qual. 2018 Dec 16;7(4):e000495. doi: 10.1136/bmjoq-2018-000495. eCollection 2018.
There is global concern over increasing antibiotic resistance rates due to poor antimicrobial stewardship, particularly in low-income and middle-income countries where there are limited diagnostic facilities, fewer doctors per capita and inadequate control over the production and sale of antibiotics. This quality improvement project was designed to improve the antimicrobial prescriptions practices of paramedical staff in the outpatient department of a rural district general hospital in Masanga, Sierra Leone, West Africa. At baseline, 57 of 66 (86%) of patients were prescribed at least one antimicrobial. On further review of 243 prescriptions for 128 patients, only 161 (66%) antimicrobials were deemed appropriate for the named diagnosis when compared with international guidelines or senior medical opinion, and 86 (35%) prescriptions had the correct drug, dose and course-length. A full, empirical antimicrobial guideline was written and introduced to local staff via a number of different methods, including: one-to-one feedback, announcements in general meetings and printed copies placed in each outpatient room. After the first cycle, the choice of appropriate antimicrobial had improved to 85% and the correct drug, dose and course-length to 53%. Unfortunately, 2 months after the second cycle, coinciding with the departure of the international internal medical physician, the rates had degraded to 65% and 43%, respectively. This study shows that implementing an empirical antimicrobial guideline can be effective at improving appropriate antibiotic prescription but that other measures are required for sustainable change. It is suggested that projects designed to change practice in low-resource countries should include national staff from the outset to improve longer term sustainability.
由于抗菌药物管理不善,全球对抗生素耐药率上升表示担忧,特别是在低收入和中等收入国家,那里诊断设施有限、人均医生较少且对抗生素生产和销售的管控不足。这个质量改进项目旨在改善西非塞拉利昂马桑加一家农村地区综合医院门诊部辅助医疗人员的抗菌药物处方行为。在基线时,66名患者中有57名(86%)至少被开具了一种抗菌药物。在对128名患者的243份处方进行进一步审查时,与国际指南或高级医学意见相比,只有161份(66%)抗菌药物被认为适用于指定诊断,86份(35%)处方的药物、剂量和疗程正确。编写了一份完整的经验性抗菌药物指南,并通过多种不同方法向当地工作人员介绍,包括:一对一反馈、在全体会议上宣布以及在每个门诊室放置印刷副本。在第一个周期后,适当抗菌药物的选择提高到了85%,正确的药物、剂量和疗程提高到了53%。不幸的是,在第二个周期2个月后,恰逢国际内科医生离开,这些比率分别降至65%和43%。这项研究表明,实施经验性抗菌药物指南可以有效改善抗生素的合理处方,但可持续改变还需要其他措施。建议旨在改变资源匮乏国家医疗行为的项目应从一开始就纳入本国工作人员,以提高长期可持续性。