Department of Neurology, University of California Davis, Davis, California.
Epilepsia. 2019 Feb;60(2):268-274. doi: 10.1111/epi.14632. Epub 2019 Jan 10.
No biomarkers reliably predict risk for sudden unexpected death in epilepsy (SUDEP). Postictal generalized electroencephalography (EEG) suppression (PGES) is a possible biomarker for SUDEP risk. However, its utility in predicting SUDEP remains uncertain. We had observed that postictal tonic electromyography (PTEMG) activity follows some generalized convulsive seizures (GCS). PTEMG activity and PGES may have a common pathophysiologic basis. PGES is associated with periictal respiratory distress. There is evidence that tonic EMG occurs with brain hypoxia. Thus PTEMG activity may be related to seizure-associated hypoxemia. Pronounced variation occurs among expert clinicians in identifying PGES, thereby limiting its utility as a biomarker. Characteristics of PTEMG activity and its relationship to preceding GCS have not been explored. We studied PTEMG activity characteristics, its relationship to the preceding seizure and associated respiratory dysfunction.
We reviewed 145 GCS in 66 patients undergoing video-EEG telemetry (VET). The presence of PTEMG activity was defined when tonic EMG occurred for at least 3 seconds following seizure termination and was identified with filter settings at 5-200 Hz. Duration of PTEMG activity, the seizure, PGES, seizure-associated peripheral capillary oxygen saturation (SpO ) change, and end-tidal CO were analyzed. We compared data from GCS with and without PTEMG activity.
Ninety of 145 seizures with GCS had PTEMG activity. The remainder had postictal slowing without PTEMG activity, and cessation of activity was followed by EEG slowing. Duration of the initial PTEMG discharge was 39.1 (mean) ± (standard deviation) 17.9 seconds. SpO nadir was lower (P = 0.005) in seizures with PTEMG activity than in those without (72% vs 77%). End-tidal CO was higher (P = 0.05) in seizures with PTEMG activity than in those without (63 vs 56 mm Hg). PGES duration was 35.6 ± 22.2 seconds and associated with duration of PTEMG activity (P < 0.001).
The novel finding is that PTEMG activity occurs following 62% of GCS and that seizures with PTEMG activity have greater severity of respiratory dysfunction than seizures without. PTEMG activity is readily discerned by visual analysis of VET at appropriate filter settings and has the potential of being a complementary or surrogate biomarker of PGES for assessing SUDEP risk.
目前尚无可靠的生物标志物能预测癫痫患者的突发性意外死亡(SUDEP)风险。癫痫发作后广泛脑电图(EEG)抑制(PGES)可能是 SUDEP 风险的生物标志物。然而,其在预测 SUDEP 中的效用仍不确定。我们观察到,癫痫后强直肌电图(PTEMG)活动跟随一些全面性强直阵挛发作(GCS)。PTEMG 活动和 PGES 可能具有共同的病理生理基础。PGES 与癫痫发作期呼吸窘迫有关。有证据表明,强直肌电图发生在脑缺氧时。因此,PTEMG 活动可能与癫痫发作相关的低氧血症有关。在识别 PGES 方面,专家临床医生之间存在明显的差异,从而限制了其作为生物标志物的效用。PTEMG 活动的特征及其与先前 GCS 的关系尚未得到探索。我们研究了 PTEMG 活动的特征,及其与先前的癫痫发作和相关呼吸功能障碍的关系。
我们回顾了 66 名接受视频脑电图监测(VET)的患者中的 145 次 GCS。当强直肌电图至少持续 3 秒时,定义存在 PTEMG 活动,使用 5-200 Hz 的滤波器设置识别。分析了 PTEMG 活动的持续时间、癫痫发作、PGES、癫痫发作相关外周毛细血管血氧饱和度(SpO )变化和呼气末二氧化碳。我们比较了有和没有 PTEMG 活动的 GCS 数据。
90 次具有 GCS 的癫痫发作有 PTEMG 活动。其余的癫痫发作后没有 PTEMG 活动的抑制,活动停止后 EEG 抑制。初始 PTEMG 放电的持续时间为 39.1(平均值)±17.9 秒。有 PTEMG 活动的癫痫发作的 SpO 最低值(P=0.005)低于无 PTEMG 活动的癫痫发作(72%比 77%)。有 PTEMG 活动的癫痫发作的呼气末二氧化碳(P=0.05)高于无 PTEMG 活动的癫痫发作(63 比 56 mmHg)。PGES 持续时间为 35.6±22.2 秒,与 PTEMG 活动持续时间相关(P<0.001)。
新发现是,PTEMG 活动发生在 62%的 GCS 之后,并且具有 PTEMG 活动的癫痫发作比没有 PTEMG 活动的癫痫发作具有更严重的呼吸功能障碍。在适当的滤波器设置下,通过 VET 的视觉分析很容易识别出 PTEMG 活动,并且有可能成为评估 SUDEP 风险的 PGES 的补充或替代生物标志物。