Thom Julia, Bretschneider Julia, Kraus Nils, Handerer Josua, Jacobi Frank
Abteilung für Epidemiologie und Gesundheitsmonitoring, Robert Koch-Institut, Nordufer 20, 13353, Berlin, Deutschland.
Psychologische Hochschule Berlin, Am Köllnischen Park 2, 10179, Berlin, Deutschland.
Bundesgesundheitsblatt Gesundheitsforschung Gesundheitsschutz. 2019 Feb;62(2):128-139. doi: 10.1007/s00103-018-2867-z.
In Germany, the significant increase of healthcare provision and service use in recent decades has not resulted in a decreasing prevalence of mental disorders.Three explanations for this phenomenon are considered: 1) prevention and the healthcare system are insufficient and ineffective, 2) the success of the healthcare service is masked by growing morbidity due to increasing societal risks, and 3) a fundamental shift towards a psychological culture accounts for an increasing perception and treatment of mental disorders and their symptoms at the same time. In order to review these three theoretical approaches, results from population-based health surveys and healthcare research in Germany as well as the international debate are presented and discussed.The present results provide evidence for each of the three explanations: 1) problems with implementation of preventive actions and access to healthcare services are well documented, 2) influences of the multifaceted development of risk factors on the prevalence and disease burden of mental disorders cannot be ruled out, and 3) a growing mental health literacy implies that problems (in everyday life) are currently more often interpreted and treated psychologically.For the purpose of evaluating changes in the healthcare system, not only should the prevalence of mental disorders be considered, but also incidence (and their potential reduction by preventive measures) as well as indicators of need for treatment (i. e. functional impairment) and mortality (i. e. suicides and reduced life expectancy).
在德国,近几十年来医疗保健服务的提供和使用显著增加,但精神障碍的患病率并未下降。针对这一现象有三种解释:1)预防措施和医疗保健系统不足且无效;2)由于社会风险增加导致发病率上升,掩盖了医疗保健服务的成效;3)向心理文化的根本转变导致对精神障碍及其症状的认知和治疗同时增加。为了审视这三种理论方法,本文呈现并讨论了德国基于人群的健康调查和医疗保健研究结果以及国际上的相关争论。目前的结果为这三种解释都提供了证据:1)预防措施的实施和获得医疗保健服务存在问题,这有充分记录;2)风险因素的多方面发展对精神障碍患病率和疾病负担的影响不能排除;3)心理健康素养的提高意味着(日常生活中的)问题目前更常从心理角度进行解读和治疗。为了评估医疗保健系统的变化,不仅应考虑精神障碍的患病率,还应考虑发病率(以及通过预防措施可能降低的发病率)以及治疗需求指标(即功能损害)和死亡率(即自杀和预期寿命缩短)。