Brurberg Kjetil G, Dahm Kristin Thuve, Kirkehei Ingvild
Tidsskr Nor Laegeforen. 2018 Dec 19;138(1). doi: 10.4045/tidsskr.17.1031. Print 2019 Jan 15.
Professionals in fields including chiropractic, physiotherapy, manual therapy and osteopathy recommend manipulation techniques for the treatment of infant torticollis. This article summarises the research evaluating such treatment.
The article is based on a search in MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL, Cochrane CENTRAL, AMED, PEDro, and the Index to Chiropractic Literature in August 2017. Controlled studies were included to assess efficacy, and observational studies to reveal the risk of harm.
We reviewed 3 418 unique hits from the literature search. We included three randomised controlled studies on the efficacy of manual therapy or osteopathy and three observational studies on possible adverse effects. Two studies on manual therapy suggested that manipulation techniques do not have any greater effect on symmetry and motor outcomes than parental guidance, physiotherapy and home exercises. One study suggested that osteopathy may contribute to increased symmetry compared to placebo, but the clinical significance of this change is uncertain. Neither the three randomised studies nor a large patient series involving 695 infants found manipulation techniques to be associated with a risk of serious adverse events, but three patient histories demonstrated that manipulation techniques may cause harm if the observed asymmetry has serious underlying causes.
Manipulation techniques have not been shown to be efficacious in the treatment of infant torticollis, but the available evidence must be considered uncertain.
包括整脊疗法、物理疗法、手法治疗和整骨疗法等领域的专业人士推荐采用手法治疗技术来治疗婴儿斜颈。本文总结了评估此类治疗方法的研究。
本文基于2017年8月在MEDLINE、EMBASE、CINAHL、Cochrane CENTRAL、AMED、PEDro以及整脊文献索引中进行的检索。纳入对照研究以评估疗效,纳入观察性研究以揭示危害风险。
我们从文献检索中筛选出3418条独立记录。我们纳入了三项关于手法治疗或整骨疗法疗效的随机对照研究以及三项关于可能不良反应的观察性研究。两项关于手法治疗的研究表明,与家长指导、物理疗法和家庭锻炼相比,手法治疗技术在改善对称性和运动结果方面并无更大效果。一项研究表明,与安慰剂相比,整骨疗法可能有助于提高对称性,但这种变化的临床意义尚不确定。三项随机研究以及一项涉及695名婴儿的大型患者系列研究均未发现手法治疗技术与严重不良事件风险相关,但有三个病例记录表明,如果观察到的不对称存在严重的潜在病因,手法治疗技术可能会造成伤害。
手法治疗技术尚未被证明对婴儿斜颈的治疗有效,但现有证据仍不明确。