Department of Community Medicine, School of Medicine, Iranian Center of Excellence in Health Management, Tabriz University of Medical Sciences, Tabriz, Iran.
Health Services Management Research Center, Iranian Center of Excellence in Health Management, School of Management and Medical Informatics, Tabriz University of Medical Sciences, Tabriz, Iran.
BMJ Open. 2019 Jan 15;9(1):e021761. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2018-021761.
The establishment of the Family Physician (FP) programme in the rural areas of Iran in 2005 has made health services accessible and affordable. This paper aims to assess the overall trends of maternal and child health (MCH) indicators in a 20-year period and possible effects of the FP programme (intervention) on these indicators in Iran.
An interrupted time series analysis was conducted on 20 annual MCH-related data points from 1994 to 2013. The intervention time was at the 12th data point in 2005.
MCH indicators were grouped into three categories: (mother's age, education, occupation and gravidity), (number of antenatal care visits (ACVs), laboratory tests, ultrasounds and natural vaginal deliveries (NVDs)) and (maternal mortality ratio (MMR), neonatal mortality rate (NMR), birth weight (BW), history of abortion and/or stillbirth, and haemoglobin level (Hb)).
The adjusted slope of the ACV trend decreased sharply after the intervention (b=-0.36, p<0.01), whereas it increased for the frequency of ultrasounds (b=0.2, p<0.01) and did not change for number of laboratory tests (b=-0.09, p=0.95). The intensification of the descending slope observed for NVD (b=-1.91, p=0.03) disappeared after the adjustment for structural confounders (b=1.33, p=0.26). There was no significant slope change for MMR (b=1.12, p=0.28) and NMR (b=0.67, p=0.07) after the intervention. The slope for the history of abortion trend was constant before and after the intervention, but it considerably intensified for the history of stillbirths after the intervention (b=1.72, p<0.01). The decreasing trend of BW turned into a constant mode after the intervention (b=33.2, p<0.01), but no change was observed for Hb (b=-0.02, p=0.78).
Although the FP programme had a positive effect on the and proximal indicators (BW), no dramatic effect on mortality outcome indicators was distinguished. It shows that there should be determinants or mediators of mortality in this setting, other than accessibility and affordability of MCH services.
2005 年在伊朗农村地区建立家庭医生(FP)项目,使医疗服务更加普及和负担得起。本文旨在评估 20 年来母婴健康(MCH)指标的总体趋势,并评估 FP 项目(干预)对伊朗这些指标的可能影响。
对 1994 年至 2013 年的 20 项年度 MCH 相关数据点进行了中断时间序列分析。干预时间在 2005 年的第 12 个数据点。
MCH 指标分为三类:(母亲年龄、教育、职业和生育次数)、(产前保健次数、实验室检查、超声检查和自然阴道分娩)和(孕产妇死亡率、新生儿死亡率、出生体重、流产史和/或死产史和血红蛋白水平)。
干预后,ACV 趋势的调整斜率急剧下降(b=-0.36,p<0.01),而超声检查的频率增加(b=0.2,p<0.01),实验室检查的次数没有变化(b=-0.09,p=0.95)。NVD 观察到的下降斜率加剧(b=-1.91,p=0.03)在调整结构混杂因素后消失(b=1.33,p=0.26)。干预后,孕产妇死亡率(b=1.12,p=0.28)和新生儿死亡率(b=0.67,p=0.07)的斜率没有变化。干预前后流产史趋势的斜率保持不变,但干预后死产史的斜率明显加剧(b=1.72,p<0.01)。BW 的下降趋势在干预后变为常数模式(b=33.2,p<0.01),但 Hb 没有变化(b=-0.02,p=0.78)。
尽管 FP 项目对 和近端 指标(BW)有积极影响,但在死亡率结局指标方面没有明显区别。这表明,在这种情况下,除了 MCH 服务的可及性和可负担性外,死亡率还有其他决定因素或中介因素。